EP1049380A1 - Method for preparing cheese - Google Patents
Method for preparing cheeseInfo
- Publication number
- EP1049380A1 EP1049380A1 EP99900716A EP99900716A EP1049380A1 EP 1049380 A1 EP1049380 A1 EP 1049380A1 EP 99900716 A EP99900716 A EP 99900716A EP 99900716 A EP99900716 A EP 99900716A EP 1049380 A1 EP1049380 A1 EP 1049380A1
- Authority
- EP
- European Patent Office
- Prior art keywords
- milk
- cheese
- phase
- nanofiltration
- carried out
- Prior art date
- Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
- Withdrawn
Links
- 238000000034 method Methods 0.000 title claims abstract description 61
- 235000013351 cheese Nutrition 0.000 title claims abstract description 56
- 235000013336 milk Nutrition 0.000 claims abstract description 55
- 239000008267 milk Substances 0.000 claims abstract description 55
- 210000004080 milk Anatomy 0.000 claims abstract description 55
- 230000001112 coagulating effect Effects 0.000 claims abstract description 14
- 238000001728 nano-filtration Methods 0.000 claims abstract description 14
- 238000000108 ultra-filtration Methods 0.000 claims abstract description 14
- 229940108461 rennet Drugs 0.000 claims abstract description 8
- 108010058314 rennet Proteins 0.000 claims abstract description 8
- 238000001223 reverse osmosis Methods 0.000 claims abstract description 8
- 239000005018 casein Substances 0.000 claims abstract description 6
- BECPQYXYKAMYBN-UHFFFAOYSA-N casein, tech. Chemical compound NCCCCC(C(O)=O)N=C(O)C(CC(O)=O)N=C(O)C(CCC(O)=N)N=C(O)C(CC(C)C)N=C(O)C(CCC(O)=O)N=C(O)C(CC(O)=O)N=C(O)C(CCC(O)=O)N=C(O)C(C(C)O)N=C(O)C(CCC(O)=N)N=C(O)C(CCC(O)=N)N=C(O)C(CCC(O)=N)N=C(O)C(CCC(O)=O)N=C(O)C(CCC(O)=O)N=C(O)C(COP(O)(O)=O)N=C(O)C(CCC(O)=N)N=C(O)C(N)CC1=CC=CC=C1 BECPQYXYKAMYBN-UHFFFAOYSA-N 0.000 claims abstract description 6
- 235000021240 caseins Nutrition 0.000 claims abstract description 6
- 238000001471 micro-filtration Methods 0.000 claims abstract description 6
- 238000011026 diafiltration Methods 0.000 claims abstract description 5
- 239000012465 retentate Substances 0.000 claims description 13
- 239000007788 liquid Substances 0.000 claims description 8
- 239000012466 permeate Substances 0.000 claims description 7
- 102000011632 Caseins Human genes 0.000 claims description 6
- 108010076119 Caseins Proteins 0.000 claims description 6
- 235000020183 skimmed milk Nutrition 0.000 claims description 5
- 235000020202 standardised milk Nutrition 0.000 claims description 3
- XLYOFNOQVPJJNP-UHFFFAOYSA-N water Substances O XLYOFNOQVPJJNP-UHFFFAOYSA-N 0.000 claims description 3
- 238000002156 mixing Methods 0.000 claims description 2
- GUBGYTABKSRVRQ-QKKXKWKRSA-N Lactose Natural products OC[C@H]1O[C@@H](O[C@H]2[C@H](O)[C@@H](O)C(O)O[C@@H]2CO)[C@H](O)[C@@H](O)[C@H]1O GUBGYTABKSRVRQ-QKKXKWKRSA-N 0.000 description 9
- 239000008101 lactose Substances 0.000 description 9
- 108010046377 Whey Proteins Proteins 0.000 description 7
- 239000005862 Whey Substances 0.000 description 6
- 102000007544 Whey Proteins Human genes 0.000 description 6
- 239000012528 membrane Substances 0.000 description 6
- 238000002360 preparation method Methods 0.000 description 6
- 239000000047 product Substances 0.000 description 6
- 230000015271 coagulation Effects 0.000 description 5
- 238000005345 coagulation Methods 0.000 description 5
- 239000012141 concentrate Substances 0.000 description 5
- 239000007858 starting material Substances 0.000 description 5
- 238000005374 membrane filtration Methods 0.000 description 4
- 235000019750 Crude protein Nutrition 0.000 description 3
- 238000004519 manufacturing process Methods 0.000 description 3
- 235000021243 milk fat Nutrition 0.000 description 3
- 239000000203 mixture Substances 0.000 description 3
- 239000002245 particle Substances 0.000 description 3
- 238000005406 washing Methods 0.000 description 3
- 235000008939 whole milk Nutrition 0.000 description 3
- 238000001704 evaporation Methods 0.000 description 2
- 230000008020 evaporation Effects 0.000 description 2
- 238000001914 filtration Methods 0.000 description 2
- 238000009434 installation Methods 0.000 description 2
- 235000020185 raw untreated milk Nutrition 0.000 description 2
- 230000035508 accumulation Effects 0.000 description 1
- 238000009825 accumulation Methods 0.000 description 1
- 230000002411 adverse Effects 0.000 description 1
- 230000015572 biosynthetic process Effects 0.000 description 1
- 239000012267 brine Substances 0.000 description 1
- 235000021383 camembert cheese Nutrition 0.000 description 1
- 238000005119 centrifugation Methods 0.000 description 1
- 239000000470 constituent Substances 0.000 description 1
- 238000007796 conventional method Methods 0.000 description 1
- 238000001816 cooling Methods 0.000 description 1
- 239000006071 cream Substances 0.000 description 1
- 230000003111 delayed effect Effects 0.000 description 1
- 238000010790 dilution Methods 0.000 description 1
- 239000012895 dilution Substances 0.000 description 1
- 230000002349 favourable effect Effects 0.000 description 1
- 239000012467 final product Substances 0.000 description 1
- 239000000796 flavoring agent Substances 0.000 description 1
- 235000019634 flavors Nutrition 0.000 description 1
- 235000011617 hard cheese Nutrition 0.000 description 1
- 239000012510 hollow fiber Substances 0.000 description 1
- 229910052500 inorganic mineral Inorganic materials 0.000 description 1
- 239000011707 mineral Substances 0.000 description 1
- 238000012986 modification Methods 0.000 description 1
- 230000004048 modification Effects 0.000 description 1
- 230000020477 pH reduction Effects 0.000 description 1
- 239000000843 powder Substances 0.000 description 1
- 238000003825 pressing Methods 0.000 description 1
- 239000002994 raw material Substances 0.000 description 1
- 235000020201 recombined milk Nutrition 0.000 description 1
- 235000020122 reconstituted milk Nutrition 0.000 description 1
- 230000005070 ripening Effects 0.000 description 1
- 238000009938 salting Methods 0.000 description 1
- 150000003839 salts Chemical class 0.000 description 1
- 238000007873 sieving Methods 0.000 description 1
- HPALAKNZSZLMCH-UHFFFAOYSA-M sodium;chloride;hydrate Chemical compound O.[Na+].[Cl-] HPALAKNZSZLMCH-UHFFFAOYSA-M 0.000 description 1
- 235000008983 soft cheese Nutrition 0.000 description 1
- 239000000725 suspension Substances 0.000 description 1
- 238000013060 ultrafiltration and diafiltration Methods 0.000 description 1
- 235000021119 whey protein Nutrition 0.000 description 1
Classifications
-
- A—HUMAN NECESSITIES
- A23—FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
- A23C—DAIRY PRODUCTS, e.g. MILK, BUTTER OR CHEESE; MILK OR CHEESE SUBSTITUTES; MAKING OR TREATMENT THEREOF
- A23C19/00—Cheese; Cheese preparations; Making thereof
- A23C19/02—Making cheese curd
- A23C19/05—Treating milk before coagulation; Separating whey from curd
-
- A—HUMAN NECESSITIES
- A23—FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
- A23C—DAIRY PRODUCTS, e.g. MILK, BUTTER OR CHEESE; MILK OR CHEESE SUBSTITUTES; MAKING OR TREATMENT THEREOF
- A23C19/00—Cheese; Cheese preparations; Making thereof
- A23C19/02—Making cheese curd
- A23C19/028—Making cheese curd without substantial whey separation from coagulated milk
- A23C19/0285—Making cheese curd without substantial whey separation from coagulated milk by dialysis or ultrafiltration
Definitions
- the invention relates to a method for preparing - cheese .
- Dutch patent application 6503328 describes a method for preparing cheese in which milk first undergoes a three-fold concentration by evaporation.
- the cold concentrated milk is treated with rennet and instantaneously coagulated with warm water, the resulting product being diluted to a concentration similar to that of the original milk.
- a drawback of this method is that an additional washing step is required when specific cheese varieties of the semihard type are prepared. In fact, the lactose content of the curd obtained during coagulation is too high. This washing step not only means an additional operation during the manufacturing process but also results in the desired higher yield not being attained.
- the concentration effected according to the above Dutch patent application takes place, as stated, by removing two thirds of the milk volume in the form of condensate. Later in the process, a similar amount of water is added again so that during coagulation an amount of whey, or resembling liquid, is produced, which amount is comparable to the amount of whey obtained in a more conventional process.
- the concentration of the milk takes place by evaporation, which is an additional process step costing much energy.
- French patent 2,052,121 discloses the so-called MMV process.
- a membrane process is used to concentrate the milk previous to the actual cheesemaking until the composition of the desired cheese has been reached.
- the concentration is effected up to a very high concentration factor, e.g. up to 8. Rennet and starter are added to the resulting concentrate.
- the coagulating process is then carried out at room temperature, disallowing the formation of separate curd particles.
- the concentrated milk can be
- the MMV process is known to give a product deviating from conventional cheese in which the whey proteins are present. Furthermore, the MMV process has only been found suitable for the preparation of soft cheeses.
- U.S. patent 4,948,599 relates to a preparation of cheese in which milk is concentrated by ultrafiltration and diafiltration. This method has the drawback that the 3
- the object of the invention is to provide a method for preparing cheese in which a high yield is realized, and in which the above prior art problems do not occur.
- the invention therefore relates to a method for preparing cheese, comprising the steps of: a) concentrating milk by means of reverse osmosis or nanofiltration in combination with ultrafiltration and optionally diafiltration and/or microfiltration to form a concentrated milk having a content of casein which is 2-4 times higher than said content of the milk; b) adding rennet to the concentrated milk and accomplishing a first phase of a coagulating process at reduced temperature in which K casein is split and a precoagulated milk is obtained; c) carrying out a second phase of a coagulating process in which the precoagulated milk is heated to obtain a curd; d) draining the curd; and e) forming the cheese.
- the composition of the final retentate can be controlled very well.
- the mineral content in the retentate is increased so that in the cheese to be prepared this content can also become higher than in conventional cheesemaking.
- the lactose content in the retentate is increased less than the protein content. The desired lactose content of the curd can then be readily adjusted by using a lactose-free warm liquid during 4
- the lactose-free permeate of the reverse osmosis or the nanofiltration can be excellently ⁇ used.
- This control of the lactose content is of special importance in the production of semihard cheese.
- the method according to the invention is energetically very favorable and gives higher yields than the methods in which no concentrated milk is used.
- the composition of the concentrate to be obtained can be adjusted. In particular, this enables adjustment of the lactose content. Consequently, the washing of the curd obtained later in the process can be avoided, even when semihard cheese varieties are prepared.
- the amount of whey, or resembling liquid, released during coagulation can be kept low. Moreover, it is advantageous that only a moderate concentration needs to be effected. Consequently, milk that has not been previously skimmed and therefore still contains a normal amount of milk fat can also be concentrated with conventional membrane types without causing serious damage to the milk fat globules. Moreover, it has been found that the present method can be carried out by means of very simple apparatus, and that the method is very flexible, namely by mixing a stream of cold retentate with a stream of warm liquid.
- the starting material for the present method is constituted by milk.
- This milk may be both raw milk and a previously completely or partly skimmed milk or standardized milk.
- the milk may also be previously thermized. According to the nature of the desired final product a skilled worker will be capable of selecting a suitable pretreatment for the starting material .
- milk is conventionally received and stored in a tank for raw milk.
- This milk may optionally be standardized for the desired fat 5
- the milk is skimmed by centrifugation and the resulting skim milk is added to the rest of the whole milk.
- This whole milk and the skim milk may then be thermized, e.g. at 65°C for 10 seconds.
- the milk may also be standardized by adding cream to the milk. After thermizing the milk is cooled and stored in a tank. Subsequently, the milk is concentrated by means of membrane filtration until the casein content is increased 2-4 times, preferably about 3 times, when compared to the casein content in the original milk.
- the membrane filtration is carried out at a temperature below 20°C, more preferably between 0 and 10°C.
- Different types of membrane filtration such as reverse osmosis, nanofiltration, ultrafiltration or microfiltration, are eligible.
- reverse osmosis or a nanofiltration is carried out first, followed by ultrafiltration and optionally diafiltration and/or microfiltration.
- different membranes may further be selected.
- the milk may be partly concentrated with a specific type of membrane, after which the final desired degree of concentration is reached with another type of membrane.
- the selection thereof may be connected, inter alia, with the desired lactose concentration in the concentrate (also referred to as retentate) , which lactose concentration, in turn, depends on the cheese variety considered for preparation and the dilution obtained in the subsequent coagulating process.
- the desired lactose concentration in the concentrate also referred to as retentate
- lactose concentration depends on the cheese variety considered for preparation and the dilution obtained in the subsequent coagulating process.
- a two-step concentration may be advantageously used, e.g. by first nanofiltering and then ultrafiltering. During nanofiltration the amount of the permeate removed may suitably be about half of the volume of the milk before concentration. Then the retentate may be further concentrated w ) N) t I- 1 ⁇ i o ⁇ i o ⁇ _ ⁇ O ( l tr ⁇ CQ t ⁇ tr CQ ⁇ Hi rt 3 rt ⁇ ⁇ tr 3 3 rt ⁇ ⁇ 3 ft ) P ) ⁇ - ft ) ⁇ ft rt tr
- the curd flakes are separated in a known manner from the liquid present (drained) and collected to a curd block. This may be achieved by using, e.g., a Casomatic ® . According to the invention it is not necessary to cut the curd. Pressing and salting the cheese may be effected in a conventional manner. If required, as in the case of cheese varieties such as nature-ripened Gouda cheese, waiting for a somewhat longer time is often required before the cheese is salted so that a sufficiently low pH is yet attained in the cheese by acidification.
- the product obtained after carrying out a method according to the invention is a traditional cheese or a product resembling traditional cheese, depending on the selected conditions. Due to an optimum coagulation and syneresis, the ready cheese has a protein content that may be just as high as that of a product of classical cheesemaking.
- the advantages of the invention are particularly obtained when a semihard cheese, such as Gouda cheese, is prepared.
- Fig. 1 shows the procedure for a preferred embodiment of the invention. The figure does not show how a nanofiltration is carried out first. The retentate of this step is subjected to an ultrafiltration, which step is not shown either. Thus the procedure is continued with an ultrafiltration retentate, which is actually a nanofiltration-ultrafiltration retentate, and with a nanofiltration permeate.
- the resulting ⁇ F permeate (1) is continuously heated to the desired temperature via a plate heat exchanger (2) and flows through a wide pipe (4) .
- an air relief cock (3) may be arranged to enable removal of air, if any, which may be particularly necessary when the process is started up.
- the discharge of the whey curd (11) is kept sufficiently high (over a bucket (7) with stirrer (8) ) , the system always remains filled.
- a sieving element (5) is preferably arranged to obtain as equal a flow as possible over the 10
- the precoagulated cold ⁇ F-UF retentate (10) distributed over one or more tubes each having a small cross-section (6) , is continuously metered in the direction of flow of the permeate.
- the outflowing concentrate coagulates and remains visible over some distance as a strand.
- these "strands" are broken to curd particles.
- the constriction is arranged to obtain an increase in the velocity so as to be less hindered in the subsequent part by local accumulations of curd particles.
- the whey curd is collected in a bucket (7) optionally provided with a stirrer (8) to further treat the curd, if desired.
- the curd is then collected in the conventional manner and pressed into a cheese vat .
- Raw RMO milk was thermized (at 65°C for 10 seconds) , bactofugated and cooled to 4°C. After thermizing and bactofugating a portion was skimmed centrifugally, and after cooling the resulting skim milk was added to the rest of the thermized and cooled whole milk of the same batch of RMO milk to obtain the correct standardization of the fat content (in relation to the protein content) for Gouda cheese.
- the milk contained 3.56% fat, 3.41% crude protein, 4.48% lactose at pH 6.69.
Landscapes
- Life Sciences & Earth Sciences (AREA)
- Chemical & Material Sciences (AREA)
- Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
- Food Science & Technology (AREA)
- Polymers & Plastics (AREA)
- Dairy Products (AREA)
- Peptides Or Proteins (AREA)
- Separation Using Semi-Permeable Membranes (AREA)
Abstract
The invention relates to a method for preparing cheese, comprising the steps of: a) concentrating milk by means of reverse osmosis or nanofiltration in combination with ultrafiltration and optionally diafiltration and/or microfiltration to form a concentrated milk having a content of casein which is 2-4 times higher than said content of the milk; b) adding rennet to the concentrated milk and accomplishing a first phase of a coagulating process at reduced temperature in which λ casein is split and a precoagulated milk is obtained; c) carrying out a second phase of a coagulating process in which the precoagulated milk is heated to obtain a curd; d) draining the curd; and e) forming the cheese.
Description
Title: Method for preparing cheese
The invention relates to a method for preparing - cheese .
In the literature different proposals have already been made to increase the efficiency of a process for preparing cheese. To attain a higher yield, different authors have suggested previously concentrating the milk which forms the starting material for cheesemaking.
Thus, Dutch patent application 6503328 describes a method for preparing cheese in which milk first undergoes a three-fold concentration by evaporation. The cold concentrated milk is treated with rennet and instantaneously coagulated with warm water, the resulting product being diluted to a concentration similar to that of the original milk. A drawback of this method is that an additional washing step is required when specific cheese varieties of the semihard type are prepared. In fact, the lactose content of the curd obtained during coagulation is too high. This washing step not only means an additional operation during the manufacturing process but also results in the desired higher yield not being attained.
The concentration effected according to the above Dutch patent application takes place, as stated, by removing two thirds of the milk volume in the form of condensate. Later in the process, a similar amount of water is added again so that during coagulation an amount of whey, or resembling liquid, is produced, which amount is comparable to the amount of whey obtained in a more conventional process. The concentration of the milk takes place by evaporation, which is an additional process step costing much energy.
Moreover, this requires the use of an evaporator of a very special type to limit damage to the milk fat globules present as much as possible so that the coagulating process is not affected too adversely.
In IDF Bulletin, Document No. 142, page 119 (1982), Lablee describes a method for preparing cheese from recombined or reconstituted milk in which the concentration of dry matter (milk powder) which is dissolved is higher than in the past. This method is of course not applicable to the preparation of cheese from fresh milk.
French patent 2,052,121 discloses the so-called MMV process. Here a membrane process is used to concentrate the milk previous to the actual cheesemaking until the composition of the desired cheese has been reached. The concentration is effected up to a very high concentration factor, e.g. up to 8. Rennet and starter are added to the resulting concentrate. The coagulating process is then carried out at room temperature, disallowing the formation of separate curd particles. The concentrated milk can be
"congealed" in a vessel having the desired shape of the cheese. The MMV process is known to give a product deviating from conventional cheese in which the whey proteins are present. Furthermore, the MMV process has only been found suitable for the preparation of soft cheeses.
The international patent application O-A-84/01268 and U.S. patent 4,689,234 describe modifications of the MMV process. The processes from both documents are particularly directed to the preparation of Cheddar cheese. French patent application 2,442,592 describes a method for preparing cheese in which milk is previously concentrated by ultrafiltration. The retentate of the ultrafiltration is cold precoagulated and then coagulated with a warm liquid. A drawback of this known method is that the lactose content of the cheese cannot be controlled properly and independently of the other constituents. This has the result that when a semihard cheese is prepared the acidity of the product cannot be controlled very well .
U.S. patent 4,948,599 relates to a preparation of cheese in which milk is concentrated by ultrafiltration and diafiltration. This method has the drawback that the
3
retentate of the filtrations is incubated at low temperature and pH. Certainly a low pH is undesirable for semihard and hard cheese varieties for the structure and yield of the cheese . The object of the invention is to provide a method for preparing cheese in which a high yield is realized, and in which the above prior art problems do not occur.
It has been found that the aims pursued are achieved when the milk used as raw material is first concentrated in a specific manner, and when the coagulating process is carried out in a special manner. More in detail, the invention therefore relates to a method for preparing cheese, comprising the steps of: a) concentrating milk by means of reverse osmosis or nanofiltration in combination with ultrafiltration and optionally diafiltration and/or microfiltration to form a concentrated milk having a content of casein which is 2-4 times higher than said content of the milk; b) adding rennet to the concentrated milk and accomplishing a first phase of a coagulating process at reduced temperature in which K casein is split and a precoagulated milk is obtained; c) carrying out a second phase of a coagulating process in which the precoagulated milk is heated to obtain a curd; d) draining the curd; and e) forming the cheese.
By combining different types of membrane filtration the composition of the final retentate can be controlled very well. On the one hand, the mineral content in the retentate is increased so that in the cheese to be prepared this content can also become higher than in conventional cheesemaking. On the other hand, the lactose content in the retentate is increased less than the protein content. The desired lactose content of the curd can then be readily adjusted by using a lactose-free warm liquid during
4
coagulation. To this end, the lactose-free permeate of the reverse osmosis or the nanofiltration can be excellently^ used. This control of the lactose content is of special importance in the production of semihard cheese. Surprisingly, the method according to the invention is energetically very favorable and gives higher yields than the methods in which no concentrated milk is used. By favorably selecting the ratio in the degree of concentration obtained by reverse osmosis or nanofiltration and the degree of concentration obtained by ultrafiltration, diafiltration or microfiltration, the composition of the concentrate to be obtained can be adjusted. In particular, this enables adjustment of the lactose content. Consequently, the washing of the curd obtained later in the process can be avoided, even when semihard cheese varieties are prepared.
Furthermore, the amount of whey, or resembling liquid, released during coagulation can be kept low. Moreover, it is advantageous that only a moderate concentration needs to be effected. Consequently, milk that has not been previously skimmed and therefore still contains a normal amount of milk fat can also be concentrated with conventional membrane types without causing serious damage to the milk fat globules. Moreover, it has been found that the present method can be carried out by means of very simple apparatus, and that the method is very flexible, namely by mixing a stream of cold retentate with a stream of warm liquid.
The starting material for the present method is constituted by milk. This milk may be both raw milk and a previously completely or partly skimmed milk or standardized milk. The milk may also be previously thermized. According to the nature of the desired final product a skilled worker will be capable of selecting a suitable pretreatment for the starting material .
To obtain a desired starting material, milk is conventionally received and stored in a tank for raw milk.
This milk may optionally be standardized for the desired fat
5
content with respect to the protein content, which depends on the cheese variety prepared. To this end, a conventional- method may be followed in which part of the milk is skimmed by centrifugation and the resulting skim milk is added to the rest of the whole milk. This whole milk and the skim milk may then be thermized, e.g. at 65°C for 10 seconds. In specific cases the milk may also be standardized by adding cream to the milk. After thermizing the milk is cooled and stored in a tank. Subsequently, the milk is concentrated by means of membrane filtration until the casein content is increased 2-4 times, preferably about 3 times, when compared to the casein content in the original milk. Preferably, the membrane filtration is carried out at a temperature below 20°C, more preferably between 0 and 10°C. Different types of membrane filtration, such as reverse osmosis, nanofiltration, ultrafiltration or microfiltration, are eligible. According to the invention reverse osmosis or a nanofiltration is carried out first, followed by ultrafiltration and optionally diafiltration and/or microfiltration. Within these types of filtration different membranes may further be selected. If desired, the milk may be partly concentrated with a specific type of membrane, after which the final desired degree of concentration is reached with another type of membrane. The selection thereof may be connected, inter alia, with the desired lactose concentration in the concentrate (also referred to as retentate) , which lactose concentration, in turn, depends on the cheese variety considered for preparation and the dilution obtained in the subsequent coagulating process.
When preparing Gouda cheese and similar cheese varieties, a two-step concentration may be advantageously used, e.g. by first nanofiltering and then ultrafiltering. During nanofiltration the amount of the permeate removed may suitably be about half of the volume of the milk before concentration. Then the retentate may be further concentrated
w ) N) t I-1 σi o σi o ι_π O ( l tr Ω CQ t Ω tr CQ Ω Hi rt 3 rt φ Ω tr 3 3 rt Ω μ 3 ft) P) μ- ft) Ω ft rt tr
Φ φ 0 tr d φ tr μ- 0 rt σi 0 ft) tr μ- tr Hi 0 0 P) tr PJ Φ μ- P μ CQ P 0 μ- tr ■^
<! φ tr Λ 3 0 P rt Φ φ Hi P μ- *< φ CQ CQ P ft Φ ft 3 CQ μ-
Ω φ φ φ CQ ft) 0 d 0 Hi CD Ω W Φ Ω < CQ Φ d φ ft) TJ Ω μ 3 O ft) Hi CQ Φ ft μ μ- CQ φ φ Φ Ω Ω H-1 Ω φ ft) rt tr 3 μ- μ Hi Ω TJ CQ 0 tr ft φ
Hi Φ φ Λ ft μ- ft φ ft Ω P 0 0 0 ft) rt P Hi d Φ Φ P rt ft) P) 0 TJ 0 P ftj ft)
Hi rt ft 3 d φ ft P 0 rt P P tr Ω Φ rt μ rt μ- rt 3 Φ μ 0 IP μ- 0 ftj Φ ft Φ μ- μ- μ- P μ rt Ω rt rt ft μ μ- φ 0 tr PJ P CQ CQ Ω μ- φ P CQ l-h CQ φ ? P 03 N P ft ft) > Φ φ ftJ H 0 ft) P 3 0 P CQ O Φ rt O Φ ft Φ μ- μ- rt rt ft Φ CQ rt Hi P P μ- rt CQ ft rt CQ Ω μ- ft ft ft) ft) P ft 0 CQ d ft rt 0
P rt P O P ft ft ft) Φ rt rt rt P Φ d μ- 0 rt Ω P μ Ω rt μ tr Hi
0 ft) tr CQ ^ ft φ ft) ft Φ • μ Φ μ- μ o rt P rt ftj h-1 0 ft Φ Φ μ- tr ft) μ- ft) Φ d tr Hi Ω tr rt rt μ ft) ft CQ Ω μ- P tr rt Φ Ω P) P P P Φ μ P CQ d rt ft) Φ O Hi Φ ft) 3 rt 0 P Φ Φ ft Ω Ω Ω Hi rt CQ μ Φ Q <
. φ H Ξ iQ μ φ Hi P -j μ- Ω Φ ftJ PJ P CQ CQ P 0 rt Φ ftJ d μ rt TJ 0 rt
Ω tr tr d P) 0 Ϊ to 0 Hi rt rt ft rt μ O P Ω μ ft Φ Ω rt Φ μ 3 o Φ μ- ft) CQ μ o ? p tr rt ω Φ d Φ Φ 0) > ft CQ r rt rt rt ft) 0 0 tr μ d »J μ P Ω P) P Φ Φ o Ω Φ 0 P TJ CQ Ω μ- Φ μ 0 tr Φ ft s; P Φ 3 3 Hi
T 0 <! TJ tr rt ft H 3 Φ μ rt rt CQ μ 0 Ω P PJ O Φ ft Ω φ φ μ- tc TJ φ X Φ ft) Ω tr ft) p P) *b H • Φ Hi 0 CQ tr rt φ μ 0 3 Φ p ftj
Φ P μ- 3 ft 0 φ ft) ft) Φ μ ft) Φ Hi 0 P ^ rt ft CQ 0 O P PJ rt 0 rt μ μ rt 0 CQ rt 0 d 0 ft μ ft X CQ Hi Hi H rt ft rt CQ TJ Ω tn rt p Φ Hi μ ft) μ- Hi tr d μ Ω ft) μ- μ- CQ μ- Hi 0 tr μ- 0 rt μ 0 P Φ μ 0 • ft
P Ω 0 Φ P μ- μ- 0 μ- rt P 3 μ- rt Hi Φ P ft tr Φ P ft) Ω ft) Hi rt rt iQ 0 P rt P rt P P P Ω l-h μ- CQ rt ft CQ rt φ φ CQ Ω CQ 0 3 tr tr P d rt μ- tr μ- μ- P ft) tr 0 Ω CQ iQ Ω p μ- Φ μ Φ Ω Hi tr Ω φ Φ d 0 Φ φ 0
P rt Φ 0 0 φ O ft CQ Ω P Φ ft) CQ 0 μ- rt Φ μ μ P P tr Hi ft) ft rt P Q μ P ft) Hi Ω CQ P 1 — ' φ μ CQ 3 rt μ- P P 0 φ J rt rt CQ μ- μ μ P
0 Hi 3 CQ 0 0 rt φ CQ rt Φ rt μ- μ- μ Ω ft) μ- ftj rt • μ Φ Φ ft PJ ftj μ- tr 0 μ- Hi d ft) ft) H μ- tr ftj μ O h-1 0 Φ Φ h-1 rt P CQ μ- ft) Λ rt Ω X rt P P φ 0 Hi CQ rt ft) Φ 3 ft) K P ft P
0 ft) T d tr rt rt μ tr <! φ 0 1-3 rt d μ 0 Ω μ- 0 σ\ rt 0 ft ? φ 0 ≤ 0 rt Ω μ- Φ ft tr Φ φ ft) 3 Φ 0 l-h s:
≤ Hi 3 rt tr I-1 ft) Φ ft 3 tr p o μ trr CQ P tr μ- ft P rt TJ TJ p μ- tr
Φ PJ 3 μ- 0 ft) rt - μ- ft) 3 μ ft ftj φ rt ft Φ CQ rt μ- 0 rt μ-
Φ rt Ω ft) rt P CQ rt 3 ft) < μ- *<; μ- rt φ Φ μ- P rt tr 0 P CQ rt Ω
P tr μ- ^ tr CQ TJ μ- rt ft) 3 ft) μ- CQ 3 rt tr ? μ- 0 ft 3 3 d • ; P Φ Hl rt μ tr φ ft Φ tr 0 tr- • ; Φ Φ P ?r Ω μ- l-h 0 Φ ' P φ φ rt ^ P 0 Φ ft) σs 0 TJ ft) P Φ rt CQ o Ω μ- P 0 rt φ ft) d rt μ T3 rt T3
• 3 rt TJ Ω μ rt 0 TJ tr ft) p μ μ-1 Ω ft rt tr P P P rt CQ μ- μ
H1 Φ 0 rt 0 0 Φ Hi T3 ft φ PJ P Ω 0 rt 0 ft) μ- tr ftj CQ 0 rt tr . rt p 0 Φ rt μ- P Ω > ft) rt φ CQ ft φ Hi μ tr P 3 φ rt rt rt μ Φ tr Φ P Hi ft) tr ft) 0 < φ CQ P rt μ- μ rt μ CQ p μ- ft ri¬ φ tr rt ft) CQ 21 Φ P) Φ
P 0 P φ ω ft) 0 ft) Φ t rt Φ d rt rt rt ft) tr P $, μ- Φ tr rt Hi Φ tr μ Ω μ f ft ft ft) P CQ ft) P CQ H d d i tr μ rt μ- μ- Φ rt ftj P ft) tr μ- Φ 3 0 pj
Φ rt rt 3 0 PJ μ Φ ft) μ 0
Hi d Hh P CQ Ω rt φ Ω P 0 ^ P tr σ\ CQ CQ μ- Ω 0 CQ μ- μ- P rt ft) P Φ μ rt tr 0 rt 0 P Ω
. rt μ- ^ 0 ft) 3 d CQ Φ N rt Ω Φ rt ft Φ tr μ- ft) P μ- ft Φ 3 μ 0 P) Φ ^ σi Φ Hi P Hi ft) P ; Φ
0 μ- μ- CQ μ- 3 ft) Φ P rt rt P μ- μ TJ Φ <J P
TJ Φ tr ftJ Hi ^ rt μ- ft p φ rt rt 0 ft) μ- ft CQ Φ Φ CQ μ- 0 <! PJ rt PJ μ- CQ ft Φ μ1 μ- P tr Hh CQ P ftJ tr P P μ- μ P rt CQ P P Φ h-1 μ σ Q Φ 0 0 Φ ,^ rt P Φ ) 0 rt tr 0 CQ φ μ φ rt ft) 0 Ό
CQ Ω CQ ft TJ l-h rt O Φ ft rt PJ tr ^ Ω Hh CQ CQ Φ h-J - P CQ P tr rt d n
P) rt 0 rt tr • >< PJ CQ 0 0 rt rt <J rt Φ rt Φ φ rt H μ- P μ- 0 μ- Ω Φ H CQ μ ? CD rt ftJ 0 rt ftJ 0 φ TJ CQ
CQ iQ d 0 ft) O • tr ft μ- 0 tr ft CO tr CQ Hi ft μ - 0 μ- 3 μ- 0
H1 ri¬ r" rt P £ μ- μ- 3 0 l_l. φ Φ Φ 0 CQ 0 μ- y P r ft) rt ft) Ω P) Hi CQ N s; tr d CQ rt rt 3 P h-1 Φ rt P h-1 μ- μ ≥
O rt ft) 0 tr Φ Φ Φ CQ PJ Ω Φ 0 o . . m
^ d 3 μ μ rt P d 0 μ- 0 CQ o
^ 3 P o ft Φ ft μ Hi P - μ- w
ft ft CQ CQ
L w to t μ> H
(Jl o σi o (Jl O (Jl
CD TJ PJ Ω P TJ α CQ TJ TJ rt μ- 0 rt TJ TJ Ξ Hi rt rt P) rt TJ μ μ μ Ω ft) μ Ω Φ 3 CQ
Φ 0 0 μ P d μ 0 0 CQ P Φ μ tr μ- tr Φ rt tr 0 Φ Φ Φ tr 3 Φ 0 ft) ft) d
Ω P) P rr 0 ft TJ Φ CQ 3 ft) Φ μ- μ φ 3 Φ CQ P P P Φ 0 P 3 μ ^ μ-
0 Ω 0 Ω Ω Φ TJ TJ CQ CQ ft) TJ Ω Ω o CQ TJ μ CD P P P Φ d P 3 rt O
P Φ ≤ Φ rt Φ μ 0 ft μ- rt μ- Φ Φ 0 tr rt μ Φ Φ P μ- φ Φ Φ CD P Φ φ μ- σ OJ O VO ft P ftJ CQ μ Hi tr ftJ CQ P μ PJ Φ μ ft Φ tr rt rt rt Φ rt rt μ φ Φ , tr μ- rt rt CQ rt rt p) P 0 rr ft) ft) iQ rt T P ftj d X • Ω μ I
T P tr μ Φ tr μ- rt Φ ft Φ rt rt d tr tr P rt Ω rt Φ μ- TJ μ- d μ- pj φ tr Φ ft) l-h Φ P μ- TJ μ d Φ P) Φ d Φ CQ Φ CQ > CD TJ H ftj μ- ftj Hi p) rt T3 0 CQ 0 rt O μ ft) ft) CQ p rt μ ft ω rt μ Ω d μ 0 P μ-1 <J
CQ rt Ω Φ ft) P 0 0 m ft) Φ rt * φ φ rt 0 d Hh Ω ftj Φ 0 ft φ Φ CQ 0 ft J h-1 tr ft) P CQ rt H- rt μ- rt φ CQ μ 0 h-1 Hi rt ^ rt ?; μ φ 0 Ω 0 0 CQ rt ft) CQ μ- μ- ft) Φ 0 Ω 0 tr CQ tr Φ TJ ft) Φ O 0 μ Φ tr tr Φ d
0 Ω CQ 3 Φ <! Φ tr ft Φ tr ftj rt P 0) Hi φ Φ M ft ft O 3 ft μ- μ Φ CD Φ α. Φ
Hi TJ 0 d μ- μ- φ P φ ft μ • TJ CQ ftJ T3 μ- ft μ- P ftj 0 • μ P 0 P rt Φ Φ ≤ Φ ,--, Φ ft) μ ft 0 Φ P tr ? M P tr TJ TJ Hi ft) Φ ft ft) μ CQ Ω P ft tr rt tr μ rt μ- Φ ft s; μ ft) P) Q O CQ rt h-1 μ ft μ 0
Ω rt 0 φ Φ tr μ- ft) tr P Ω CQ Φ PJ rt < tr ^ 0 Φ μ Hi
Ω 0 TJ μ- μ rt CQ P CQ X rt l-h tr φ Ω rt Φ 0 d ft t rt tr CD μ- 0 rt rt Φ ft Ω CD
0 ft) tr 0 φ ftJ μ- ft d rt tr 0 0 tr d μ- ft) -1 o d Φ 3 P Hi 0 0 ftj d 0 Φ μ- ft) CQ ft) P 3 3 μ- Ω Φ μ s- CQ μ Ω CQ CQ rt ftJ o o μ ft) CQ Ω P Ω P P rt
CQ d CQ ft Φ d rt tr ft Φ Φ φ rt φ 0 d μ- rt Φ 3 l-1 rt rt 0 rt Ω rt rt d Φ μ- μ- CQ μ- OJ μ <: tr 3 ra p • Φ P) tr O tr P ftj Φ μ- ftJ P P rt 0 P) ^ Φ Ω Φ φ φ CQ TJ TJ PJ CQ ft) rt Φ Φ σ Φ <l 3 p P
< 3 μ- D ft) rt d CQ TJ PJ P Q • P 0 μ Ω φ H-1 rt T3 tr μ D φ 0 0 rt Φ CQ rt μ- P s; P CQ P P rt μ H Φ μ- μ- Ω rt φ 0 rt Ω 3 H- P d ≤ μ rt -S μ- 0 ft tr TJ ft) Φ Ω > Φ rt Φ Φ φ rt rt P 0 Φ μ Φ ft P) μ 0 P rt P ft) tr ft μ-
P P Φ μ- d Ω 0 rt P) rt rt μ- rt ft P Ω Φ •» tQ 0 3 Hi 3 Φ P - <! μ- rt 0 rt 0 CQ
CQ μ Ω 3 Φ d tr P 0 P rt TJ Φ rt
CQ 0 P Ω Φ 0 tr Φ ft CD tr μ- tr TJ CQ Φ Ω rt 0 d rt Φ Φ CQ TJ TJ Φ Φ μ P) d CQ φ TJ P P 0 rt . 0 Φ
TJ P 0 ftj ft) h-1 μ- tr P μ- ft) Φ rt ft TJ μ μ ft μ 0 PJ P rt P μ rt ft) Hh ft) ft -J μ TJ ft tr rt > -: Hi d PJ Φ P 3 μ-1 o ftJ o tr Φ rt tr rt Φ μ- l-1 μ- φ T
0 3> rt H 3 rt CQ H-1 TJ μ- μ- μ- Hi Ω Ω rt ft CQ μ Hi 0 rt p 0
Ω tr μ- Ω Φ μ- 0 ft 0 Φ Q P r Φ φ 0 d t) rt s; μ rt μ CQ p μ μ ^ tr 0 ft) Φ P 3 tr φ CQ CQ ft
Φ μ- 3 d • φ P Ω Ω 3 f d Hh rt μ Φ Φ ft CQ rt ω n d μ ft) Ω tr 0 ^ tr OJ ft) rt μ- P) CQ Ω Φ Φ 0 rt Φ P) rt rt μ- Φ
CQ tr 3 ft H CQ P d 3 Φ rt rt ft tr P tr Φ CQ rt P I-1 d ft tr tr rr 0 μ- μ- tr μ rt rt 0 0 Φ ft) tr d ft Φ CQ rr p tr tr CQ rt o Φ 0 μ CQ p μ- Ω μ- μ ft) μ P P 3 Φ μ Φ ^ tr rt Φ f—1 φ Φ tr - 3 • ; ft ft Φ rt Q 0 CQ μ- s: 3 rt μ- ri¬ ft Φ Φ ft CQ 0 Φ μ rt μ μ- en μ- Φ CQ Φ ft) rt 0
Ω P CQ μ- PJ μ- ft r TJ ft) l-h Ω P CQ ftJ 0 μ • CD o Hh 3 μ ft tr rt
Ω ft) ft 0 rr P φ ft) rt tr μ ftJ 3 o rt s; Φ o ?f μ TJ Hi ft Φ 0 ftJ ft) CQ μ- tr rt tr CQ 0 0 φ OJ P φ rt rt Φ ft) P H tr 0 0 0 Φ rt ft μ Φ rt tr Ω Ω ft Ω tr ft tr TJ ftJ ft H1 μ f Hi ft ft μ μ- μ- ftJ Φ ft tr ftJ 3 0 Ω • 0 0 μ Φ I-1 Φ P tr ft) CD 3 0 μ Hi t
O Φ Φ CQ rt ftj Φ 3 0 rt α TJ ^ 0 ft μ- P 0 μ- μ Φ Φ P OJ ft) 0 ft) d μ rf.» Φ TJ to ft) μ ft CQ
Φ P P Φ Φ ft ^ CQ P H cQ rt ft) P rt CQ μ- O 0 rt tr μ Φ o ft μ p 3 rt ft μ- CQ Φ tr P) CQ d rt rt d ? CQ Φ μj • μ- Φ tr Hi Φ rt rr ft)
CQ • ft ; Φ CQ
^ tr μ- σ\ Φ Φ Ω T ? ri¬ CQ P Φ rt Φ rt ft) TJ 0 ft) 0 tr μ
0 3 Φ Φ OJ P μ- ft) CQ ft) ^ H-J ft) P μ- 0 3 ft) 3 Hi φ rt d oi rt T ft rt d CQ rt tr P) CQ • PJ 0 μ- J Φ μ μ- P) 0 μ *»
0 P 0 Φ "0 rt TJ 0 0 PJ ftj μ- Φ Φ CQ φ G p ft rt Φ W tr Λ d μ- d OJ CD μ
• n
CQ P μ- μ- ft 0 Λ ft d ft μ- H Φ Φ ft CQ O P P rt p r H μ- rt CQ ft P P ft P rt d Hi φ ft P tr • ; ft Φ μ- d ft) μ-; rt CQ μ- rt PJ ^
H rt ft) μ- CQ CQ Φ tr μ- TJ CQ TJ tr μ- μ- ft CQ h-1 s: 3 3 μ rt tr1 tr . tr rt ft Φ rt μ . Φ Φ CQ P P) rt 0. 0 Φ 0 rt tr vo d Φ h-1 tr ft Φ 0 P rt tr ftj ft) 0 o Hi CQ vo
Hi Λ μ- —
CQ ft) Φ Φ 0 •<; ft ft P) Φ rt ft rt ft) μ CQ O
Φ Φ d rt μ- ? P ft tr rt 0 rt CQ rt Ω P Φ ftj φ P) Hi tr
0 • rt CQ m ft rt Φ
C J > to to
(Jl o in o (Jl o in
ft) ft) < CD 3 Ω J J ft) rt rt ft) TJ 0 tr rt P Hi TJ 0 Hi r s> TJ 3 μ Ω μ- rt μ tr ftJ rt μ- d ω μ μ P μ tr CQ μ ft Φ PJ tr ft) ftJ μ- μ μ Φ ft) μ ft) φ O P tr
0 μ μ X μ φ Φ φ ft φ Φ Φ tr r Ω Φ rt P 0 ft) 3 μ Φ rt to ft) < Φ d Φ μ- Φ μ- ft T3 Ω Hi ft) 3 rt Ω Φ £ rt Φ 0 rt Ω tr - 3 3 Q Φ d CQ Φ
P φ P P PJ 0 φ TJ rt 0 0 μ Φ 0 ft μ Hi μ Φ μ- Φ Φ Φ μ d P TJ ft rt rt CQ CQ Hi μ &) μ μ 3 Hi ft) Φ CO Φ μ- ft) CQ iQ CQ μ P μ- r rt ,μ
0 ^ rt J CQ ft) Φ Φ μ 3 CQ tr P Φ CQ . — . rt CQ tr ft) ft) rt ftj μ- ft) μ- lφ ^) rr tr rt p) rt d tr Ω P 0 ftJ d ft) μ- 0 rt μ- Φ rt r rt P rt O Ω tr CD Ω Φ Φ ? μ- > 0 rt 3 x H-1 P rt Ω μ μ μ 0 X μ- μ 0 d Φ μl Ω CQ μ- P 0 φ Φ 0 P 3 φ 0 ft) Hi *< ft) • Φ ft) ft tr 0 Φ in P Φ CQ • μ μ t O o O )
P φ TJ CQ P rt rt CQ tr rt Φ P ft 0 rt μ tr Φ φ g Hi Ω P rt CQ
Ω Φ 01 ft Φ Φ Φ I-1 d > Φ CQ Φ Ω rt μ- 3 Φ Ω T3 Φ 0 r d tr d d Ω μ- μ P) O ft μ . μ- d ft ft) Ω Φ tr 0 ft) PJ μ μ- μ Ω μ- Ω μ 0 ft) μ rt ft ftj ftj μ Hh in ftj Hi P Hi d P ftJ Φ P ^ rt μ Φ Hi CQ 0 P tr ft Ω rt ft) ft φ rt rt φ Ω ft) .. rt ft) CQ Hi Ω CQ μ rr Ω μ tr μ Hi o ftj 0) Φ Ω rt ft) μ d 0 tr μ Φ < μ- 0 d α μ rt TJ tr Φ μ- Φ μ CD ft rt Φ rt d μ- Φ
Hi Φ ftJ μ CQ μ- P 0 • ft O ft Ω P Hi PJ O φ Φ φ μ 3 d μ μ- CQ d μ P ft
I-1 CQ ft Φ rt ►Q Ω d μ ft) μ- Ω Hi Hti rt CD μ- μ TJ ft 0) Φ Hi Φ J 0 φ μ CQ ft) d tr μ d Φ rt 3 ft) 3 φ Φ μ- -> μ- φ & 3 ft) Φ tr ft Hi CQ μ P 3 P • rr 3 μ- H μ- μ- φ μ- P μ- tr OJ P P Ω ft 0 d Φ ft μ 0 i-1 μ- Φ Φ ft) CQ tr μ-
Φ rt 0 Q CQ P ft rt (Jl H-" H-1 IQ rt rt μ- P Ω μ- ft) 3 d • ; Ω g Ω O - en μ- M
CQ ft) μ tr CQ — μ X Φ Φ μ φ Φ 0 ft rt ft Φ r - m μ- r_r 0 Hi μ- 0 d 03 tr φ μ- rt ft rt ft μ ft) P CD μ- P Φ P OJ tr Φ J P d μ
CQ TJ μ 3 tr rr rt 0 μ 0 rt rt co Ω rt r OJ rt μ- P μ- CQ 3 Q r TJ 03 μ- μ Φ μ TJ Φ PJ Φ ftj 0 rt 0 Φ ft Φ 3 ft) ft) Φ rt tr CO rr P d φ μ rt CD φ φ rt 0 P x ft I-1 P 0 3 ft ft) P μ P p) CD CQ μ- CQ μ- rt μ- Φ ft) 3 TJ Φ μ Φ φ o CQ d 0 3 ft Φ rt ^ Φ μ OJ CQ μ- ^ OJ cr CD O CQ J tr rt μ- ft) 3 rt ft CQ 3 φ 3 Hi 3 0 ft) μ tr 0 Φ D rt μ μ- Φ t-1 X μ TJ PJ μ- 3 CD Φ 3 0 μ- d rr Ω ft) tr Φ d H-1 rt CQ tr μ- Φ OJ Ω tr P ft) ft)
^ μ- ft) Φ P J μ- d μ P ^ tr r Φ ftj CQ Φ Φ φ rt H- ιQ ft P o Φ CQ rt
P rt μ rt HI I-1 ?r p tr μ Ω ? rt Φ Φ μ- rt H^ 0) 3 Ω tr IQ d Φ P l-1 <! Φ ∞ μ CQ μ- ftJ P ftJ Φ ft) tr rt ft 0 CD μ- ^ CQ TJ 0 Φ tr μ- g Ω < Φ tr Ω ft) ftj rt rt ^ ft
Φ 0 rt tr ≤ 0 CD P Φ P Φ Φ P ft μ- Hi Φ Φ μ
03 r P d φ rt Φ P l-h ≤ μ- ft Φ μ- Hi d ftj H-1 CQ d ft μ ft Ω rt μ- P μ "<
Φ Φ •" μ Ω tr ft rt Φ 0 d -1 μ Hi μ- Φ CQ OJ ft) 0 03 X -~ rt ^ rt H
3 3 φ PJ μ- 01 Φ Φ μ Ω i-1 Ξ μ rr P Ω φ ft rt TJ O 0 rt μ tr Hi rt tj1 TJ ft) • d CQ J rt μ P 0 μ- d ftJ 0 Φ rt μ- ft d d tr φ 3 μ- μ ft) CQ Φ ft)
Φ CQ 0 tr H P μ tr rt d μ rt Φ i-Q •» μ μ 0) 0 rt CQ ft) r 0 CQ μ-
Φ μ ω Ω Φ Ω P Φ 3 OJ cQ ft ft) Φ P tr ft d μ- Φ Q ft) 3 tr rt Φ 0 Λ rr 03
CQ ftj μ- 0 rt μ- • • < μ ft CD φ μ- μ- P Φ rt Φ ft) TJ μ- ft ft d rt H- <! rt P ftJ S. x ^ ft) rt Hi φ μ- 0 J ft P (Q 0 P rt μ O ft) 03 ft) s- d φ tr P P OJ μ- μ μ ≤ P 3 3 ft) Hi 0 rt rt Φ P tr tr J P tr μ P Φ Φ Φ μ p ftJ 3 ft) ft) rt μ- CQ φ μ- μ TJ 3 Hi Φ ft) rt Hi ^ Φ μ- O
Φ Φ Φ Ω 0 3 iQ P P 0 rt X rt Hi ft) Φ ) 3 μ tr Φ 3 Ω rt P ft)
*< • ft ftj CQ rt d ft Ξ CD φ tr rt r M tr μ o rt TJ μ- φ μ Φ
H- CD S rr ft) J CQ r μ- μ- d ^ Φ rt cl 3 ft) ^ rt ft
1 tr Φ 0J rt φ d PJ <!
H ≤- CQ P 0 ft) tr ω rt 0 φ μ Λ 3 μ μ- μ if--. Φ μ ^ 3 tr tr ft) CO O P ft) tr 0 TJ Φ P ^ rt Φ • • Φ μ rr Φ d Φ Φ ft ft) Ω PJ o ft) μ- 0 P φ Hi Φ P
Φ μ φ μ Φ I-1 μ rt 0 CQ CD μ- - Φ 3 d p o Ω rt ft) "< ft CD O rt - Ω Φ rt CD μ Φ TJ ft tr TJ 0 Φ n 0 d μ- CO rr rt d ft) -> Φ H- CQ tr 0 tr 0 ftJ J h-1 Φ ^ s Φ d OJ • OJ μ P 0) . 0 tr tr 03 CQ μ- μ Hi H- Φ CQ d Hi P μ Φ Ω tr P P μ CQ φ 0 Q ft Hi Φ Φ Φ O i-Q μ- CQ rr ^ rt ft Φ Ω rt O Φ μ- ft rt d CD ^ ft H d s Ω CQ tr P TJ - — <J rt P X Ω μ- rt ι-j φ rt to 0 μ- μ- μ- φ ft) Φ μ- Φ 0 Φ Φ rt a tr P 0 tr ft) O Ω ft tr rt Hi ft Ω CQ rt μ Q μ μ P ft 0 rr tr CQ Hi Φ rt Hi d Φ ft) r tr Φ Φ 3 r t ft μ- μ rr μ rr vo Φ Ω rt Q 3 Φ CQ rt Φ P 0 P to ft O rt tr o tr Φ rt tr μ- 0 ft) 0 tr iQ P CQ σι μ- o φ o
Φ CD Φ φ CD CO rt φ φ 0 P OJ
Φ ft rt Φ O CQ
9
_ Finally, the curd flakes are separated in a known manner from the liquid present (drained) and collected to a curd block. This may be achieved by using, e.g., a Casomatic®. According to the invention it is not necessary to cut the curd. Pressing and salting the cheese may be effected in a conventional manner. If required, as in the case of cheese varieties such as nature-ripened Gouda cheese, waiting for a somewhat longer time is often required before the cheese is salted so that a sufficiently low pH is yet attained in the cheese by acidification.
The product obtained after carrying out a method according to the invention is a traditional cheese or a product resembling traditional cheese, depending on the selected conditions. Due to an optimum coagulation and syneresis, the ready cheese has a protein content that may be just as high as that of a product of classical cheesemaking. The advantages of the invention are particularly obtained when a semihard cheese, such as Gouda cheese, is prepared. Fig. 1 shows the procedure for a preferred embodiment of the invention. The figure does not show how a nanofiltration is carried out first. The retentate of this step is subjected to an ultrafiltration, which step is not shown either. Thus the procedure is continued with an ultrafiltration retentate, which is actually a nanofiltration-ultrafiltration retentate, and with a nanofiltration permeate.
The resulting ΝF permeate (1) is continuously heated to the desired temperature via a plate heat exchanger (2) and flows through a wide pipe (4) . At the beginning thereof an air relief cock (3) may be arranged to enable removal of air, if any, which may be particularly necessary when the process is started up. When during the process the discharge of the whey curd (11) is kept sufficiently high (over a bucket (7) with stirrer (8) ) , the system always remains filled. At the widening of the line a sieving element (5) is preferably arranged to obtain as equal a flow as possible over the
10
entire_width of the line. The precoagulated cold ΝF-UF retentate (10) , distributed over one or more tubes each having a small cross-section (6) , is continuously metered in the direction of flow of the permeate. The outflowing concentrate coagulates and remains visible over some distance as a strand. However, when reaching the constriction (9) , these "strands" are broken to curd particles. The constriction is arranged to obtain an increase in the velocity so as to be less hindered in the subsequent part by local accumulations of curd particles. The whey curd is collected in a bucket (7) optionally provided with a stirrer (8) to further treat the curd, if desired. The curd is then collected in the conventional manner and pressed into a cheese vat . The invention will now be explained in further detail by means of the following examples, which are not intended to limit the invention.
Example I
Raw RMO milk was thermized (at 65°C for 10 seconds) , bactofugated and cooled to 4°C. After thermizing and bactofugating a portion was skimmed centrifugally, and after cooling the resulting skim milk was added to the rest of the thermized and cooled whole milk of the same batch of RMO milk to obtain the correct standardization of the fat content (in relation to the protein content) for Gouda cheese. The milk contained 3.56% fat, 3.41% crude protein, 4.48% lactose at pH 6.69. The next day 180 liters of this standardized milk were concentrated to a fat content of 6.94% and 6.44% crude protein (concentration factor 1.93) at 10°C by means of nanofiltration (installation type ΝF-40, spiral wound PA membranes 6 m2). Subsequently, further concentration was effected by means of ultrafiltration (Romicon installation, hollow fiber, type PM-IO(PSJ), 3 m2, cut-off 10,000 daltons) at 15-20°C to 9.51% fat and 8.79% crude protein (total
C J to t μ> (Jl o in o in (Jl
CD 03 03 tr Ω ft) Ω ftj s; 3 ft) Ω rt to T Ω μ- ft) T3 Ω a ω PJ ft) TJ Ω Ω ft) Φ tr Φ o Ω O tr ft) μ- O Φ rt d O P O p d ft o\° • P ft) ft) O μ- to Ω o ft) μ- o 03 P O P μ 3 d rt P μ tr LJ- σi ft to μ P
3 O CQ CQ ft d d P rt Φ TJ Ω O o ≤ Ω μ- 03 d CQ rt μ Ω
CO Φ rr μ- 3 Φ rt rt rt CQ μ- φ ft) μ- ft ft) Φ Ω Φ 03 rt g rt Φ μ- Φ vo vo P
3 ft ft ft) Hi P μ φ P μ 3 ft) d μ- CD P tr rt ft) S tr d φ ,P μ- μ- 03 μ ft) μ- rt ft) CQ d ft) rt 3 tr ft) P rt 3 d Φ μ Φ μ ft Irt i rt rt rt Ω μ- P μ- O rt Φ rt CQ rt μ Φ Φ ft rt TJ p μ- μ Os
M tr φ μ- ft) Hi O CQ rt d d ttoo μ> μl Ω Φ * ft) P P Φ tr N O ft)
Φ X φ ft O rt tr P d > tr 03 μ
σ\ tr tr μ- μ ft) Φ rt rt rt rt μ o Ω φ d rt ft tr tr ft) P H- d ft) ft) φ Hi Φ φ P Φ O to o ft rt μ- ) ft> ft) P o CQ μ μ rt rt Ω O TJ t 03 TJ
P o f o o CQ Ω Ω rt o o r P rt μ Φ tr d μ μ Hi σi < φ tr K tr P
Φ rt μ P tr ft) 3 Φ Φ μ Φ μ PJ tr tr μ- Ω 8 O g - μ ft) Φ μ- ftj
P) P O tr Φ Φ Φ s- ft) μ ft ft CD <! μ- σι ω Φ rt ft rt rt Hi t rt Hh pj ft) ts P ft) p, Φ f φ tr ft ∞ _ o o Φ tr Ω ft) ft μ d o ft TJ CD ft) P O rt Hi l o P ft o μ • Φ ft) rt tr Ω φ μ- CQ Hi ft) X tr Φ Hi O ft CJ1 Hi ft Ω s- d O Φ ft O ft) rt ft Hi ft) Hi 03 > : μ μ ft) • o Φ r rt TJ si d μ- ft 3 μ- O rt μ Φ O O ft) ft) r (Jl Ω P μ O D tr ftj rt Φ μ- *> rt co μ rt CQ Φ ft) ft) Hi 3 Ω P μ- Φ o ft) o Ω Φ Φ CD ft) Ω tr ft X ° d Φ 0 ft) ft rt ft) φ o Ω P CQ o μ P Φ 03 o μ ft) rt π _ to d rr rt ≤ d tr tr μ- ft) 3 rt O o o p
P ft) Hi 03 ft ft) r d Φ rt ft) μ Φ tr tr ft o Φ p P s; μ- rt ft μi 3 O Ω rt Φ Hi O μ H -J tr * P Φ μ φ ft) ft) d Φ CQ ft Φ s- P μ ft φ TJ tr O P < φ d1 ^ tr — t)
Φ - • ft μ μ φ rt Φ
O CO rt μ to μ ft) d ft) Φ μ Φ μ- rt Ω Ω Φ rt Ω φ 1 rt O r ft Hi Ω Φ Φ μ rt Φ t ; tr f r ≥ CQ φ to f) Ω Ω O Φ d Φ d Ω ft s; p μ- ft) rt μ W μ t 3 o tr tr Q tr rt μ- Φ P O 0 Hi Φ Φ Φ tr <! 3 Hi ft μ CD rt μ- μ Φ P 03 Φ Φ Φ O
03 ft 0 Φ o Φ Φ ft) φ o μ- o rt rt o μ- ft) ft μ Φ CQ tr! d CD rt rt rt Ω CD 3> CO rt Φ μ 0) o ^ ft) tr d P
(Q CQ rt Φ rt 3 Ω d μ d tr ft) Φ tr tr φ Φ Ω Ω 3 rt Hi CD rt Φ μ ft) o Φ μ- H f) p f μ- Φ O tr rt Φ Φ TJ tr μ P rt ^ ft) P t N rt 3
O l-h t rt rt ft) CQ Φ o o Φ ft) Φ ft d rt Φ Φ ft) tr o ϋ 03 Ω φ μ- Φ
Φ rrtt CO CD ft) Hi Φ P ft) ft Φ ft rt φ n ft rt Φ μj μ P 3 rt
μ 0O Ω Φ 03 rt 03 ft tr Φ T X Φ Φ μ ft) P TJ cQ tr rt tr tr Φ o μ- tr ft) in Φ μ rt O ft Ω d ft φ 3 rt tr ft) μ f) o φ Ω tr Φ tr in t ιn ft) d P μ- Hi ft Φ Φ d O P P o μ o rt Ω ft) t) rt Φ ftj rt o s: Hi r Ω rt O rt CQ O o TJ Ω P Ω f d ft) rt
03 rt O O Φ μ 03 ft in ft rt ft) tr Φ <! O rt μ- d ft rt rt TJ tr O p
-J tr Hi tr rt Φ 3 φ O 00 (£) CQ Φ μ μ- h-1 p ft) rt o CQ tr Φ P Φ to Ω Φ μ- μ- μ o CD μl ft) tr P d Ω j rt rt ft) o Φ TJ μ P > N ft) TJ μ- tr fj μ> CD
Φ c H3 t Φ ft) Ω p μ rt CQ ft) T TJ P 0 ftft)) μ ft) 3 Φ Hi Z φ ft) O P rt tr Φ O rt μ o Hi tf) φ ft) rt o
H- TJ Φ μ ' tu ft d C CQQ μ- < Φ π> ft) rt μ- φ P 3 Hi μ Ω t μ- μ 03 $, P Φ 3 IQ rt in φ O PJ Φ N rt o f
Φ tr μ φ 0 03 03 TJ 03 ft) d Hi 3 μ- i r μ- -- Φφ tr tr μ P ft) CQ P ft 03
O ft) μ rt CD ft Φ rt rr
Hi ft) μ φ μ- rt ft) d μ- X ft) rt ft μ- Φ rt Φ tr μ- O Ω rt ft) Φ CD μ- ft) μ- ft) Φ ft rt Φ Hi μ X CD CQ Φ T X Ω rt Hi ft) μ O rt in rr Hi TJ μ- 03 rt rt μ- P tr rt tr d CD Ω Hh μ tr en μ- Φ rt rt in Φ
CD P - rt CQ P J Ω σ\ μ PJ μ- P Φ tr P ft) O Φ rt o C μ- Φ ft) ft CQ in to P Φ μ P Q rt μ Φ CQ rt P P o O TJ ft rt TJ μ CO CO n f! 0 d rt o o CQ μ Φ tr μ d tr Ω ft Ω Φ t t ft) X P^ P Φ φ H
Ω tr O
ft rt rt μ- ft) TJ tr Ω
0 Φ Hi μ φ n Ω o Ω μ O φ O rt Φ ft) Ω tr μ- tr Ω O Φ CD P d ft) rt μ- € o r 0 μ- μ Hi P O Φ 3 o ft) μ-
Φ rt to μ- « ft ft) ft! P P P Φ O ft d φ Ω d μ P μ- μ • ft) φ H CO p ft rt rt rt
Φ CQ o μ tr d μ P ftj (Jl 03 tr 03
- ft
0 μ μ- rt μ-
Φ o
O o ft Hi ft Φ μ>
Hi ft σi φ ft)
Φ o ft a O tr o P ft
00 OJ to to μ> h1 in o in o in o in
Ω PJ tr Ω 0 d μ- 03 S 03 h-1 μ TJ Ω en CTi Co ft) Ω ft) Ω 3 μ- X Ω CD P TJ Ω ft) 3 03 Ω ≤ d ft) O Hi P 3 ft) Φ μ- Φ X 0 < o d P 0 P 0 Φ Ω P •T. 0 TJ ftj μ 0 rt μ- φ 0 tr μ rt < P Ω 3 Ω rt Ω rt ft) P tr ft 0 ft P 3 0 03 « P μ- P 0 P h-1 Ω P 0 ft Φ μ- CD ft) tr φ 3 Φ rt Φ ft ≤ Ω 3 03 Ω Q* P rt Ω μ 0 rt Ω TJ X 0 rt
3 P r ft) ft μ μ- μ μ- ft) φ f h-1 φ OJ Φ 03 Φ μ Ω ft) H1 Φ ft) Hi φ Φ X P Φ Φ
≤ TJ CQ μ 03 P μ- ft) 0 CD CO P Φ Λ o\° ft d P PJ Φ h-1 00 P μ- μ- P Ω ft P
PJ Φ μ- 3 C ) rt ^-, P ^ rt Φ Ω d tr rt P P -> I-1 rt P rt en 0 03 rt 13
CD μ ft) Ω ft) Φ rt ^ TJ rt μ d ft) Φ 03 rt 03 μ φ rt ft) μ ≤ rt μ • P • μ- ft) rt ft Φ μ> 00 0 Φ t-3 TJ tr ft) s- h-1 P rt 0 Φ ft) μ rt ft) 0 μ ftj -j rt S σ
CQ rt Ω μ- in o Hi μ tr d Φ rt ft) Hi rt ft) Λ rt TJ 0) μ- CQ rt d ft) Ω rt o ft) μ- H3 X
Ω d μ 0 tr ^ o Ω μ- 3 P Φ μ μ in d Φ μ rt 0 J μ- P rt 0 Φ • μ- rt tr
0 μ 0 P Ω d 03 tr 03 TJ ft ft μ ^ rt o Φ 0 μ- P O ft μ- P ft P tr μ- rt
O Φ Q tr rt ft) 0 Φ en Φ Φ Φ Ω P s- Ω 0 — ^ P 0 Ω H Φ 03 0
TJ CO μ- ft) P μ- tr 3 d TJ ft • 3 P_ P μ r PJ Φ P T3 P Φ rt tr ft rt φ 0 1 P P tr ft rt 3 μ μ in μ- P *. - 03 03 rt to P 0 Φ tr 3 0 ft Hi CD cQ μ Φ μ-
Φ PJ H Φ C 3 0 ft) ---. rt oo Φ μ- σ
Φ rt Φ o X μ Ω d ^ CQ Hi tr μ- ftj Ω h • i s> rr 3 rt tr
P P 0 rt Φ CQ a σ Φ ft) 3 CD 3 μ- μ ft) P . h-1 rt μ- OJ Ω tr x Φ 03 TJ Φ CQ Ω H φ P ft) φ £> ftj T ft)
P O rt Φ μ- Φ TJ ft ft) Φ ι-3 3 μ ,--. CO ft) J rt o Φ g CD rt Hi ft! Φ CD T3 Φ φ X O TJ μ- rt • μ- P rt TJ Hi rt CQ μ tr 03 rt ≤ 0 • Hi CJ1 rt μ- ft) rt o\o TJ ≤ P
0 in 0 rt ft) Φ h-1 tr rt Φ rt Φ Φ f) ft)
0 P d rt Hi Hi μ 0 3 d Φ 03
Φ Φ CO ft) μ P do d μ oo 03 Hi μ ft) 0 rt t
Φ ft μ -J TJ Φ ft) }-> P ft Hi μ to rr ft) Ω tr tr rt I-1 rt ft) rt CQ ft Φ μ- 0 Φ P d φ μ- oV μ- Ω P Ω ft) ft) ft) tr
P 0 Φ Φ Φ 0 tr Φ ft Φ rt μ- μ- rt ft P Ω CQ μ d P μ rt φ ft) Hi 0 ^ rt rt rt Φ
P € Hi . μ s 0 ft μ- μ Φ μ Λ 0 Φ CQ μ- ~ rt μ- — ' TJ Ω l-h ft) Φ CD rt ft) P •« d tr d ft) μ μ- d μ Φ ft μ d μ ft rt H-1 1 N P) rt ft) I— ' ft — μ- Ω rt H to Φ Ω
CQ in > ft) ft) P μ μ- Φ P ft μ- μ- Φ tr S Φ rt μ O rt • 0 rt Φ M oo P O ft) Hi rt tr CQ Ω Ω P ft ft TJ μ- Φ ft 0 μ rt ≤ tr P 0 P O • Ω μ μ Ω Ω rt Φ 0 rt t) <! 0 CQ Φ μ> d μ μ- ft) ft) 0
0 * O μ rt O OJ 0 TJ μ
\— ' 3 Φ d ft) μ3 f μ- μ- p • Ξ d μ o 3 φ rt tr ft) in φ H1 P d d rt oo P ft) Φ
<! tr μ» μ o rt 0 ft) Ω ft) P rt in ft ft P 3 tr to 0 H1 o\° < CD Ω
Φ 1— ' Hi 0 φ rt f Φ CD ^ . Hi μ- φ rt r
03 Φ rt tr σi P d P Φ CD rt H1 UT Ω ft) φ 0 oo t . tr p μ- O o ft) ft -J Ω 0 • μ> ft) Φ Φ o rt Ω P Φ
03 Ω tr ft) Hi o CQ Ω 0 rt μ O o P ft CQ to d μ> o T_l P lb φ> -J Φ μ rt d CO φ rt Φ ft) ft Φ ft) 0 ft) rt rf» • > CD S5 . μ d μ- μ rt h-1 Φ < l-1 0 Φ Hi rt μ
Ω Hi P r CΩ μ- tf 3 Ω P d μ- 0 -* .- Φ ^ ft ≤ P s: 3 0 Ω tr d ft) rt μ> 03 ft 0 μ- ft)
03 Hi tr rt tr tr μ- α ft Φ ft tr 00 3 0 t) t Φ ft) P 1 f P N P tr (Q μ Φ Φ Φ Φ rt d rt Hi o\° φ Hi e rt o\<= O ft Φ ft
Ω μ- Φ Ω rt P 0 CD μ Φ 3 0 ft) 0 tr ft) σ rt hf rt 3 P ft) O Hi ft ft)
0 ^ Hi tf) 0 03 rt μ- ≤ P μ Ω Hi μ 0 TJ
Ω CQ Ω tr P £ 3 d ^ ft) μ μ
P 1 -> d 0 μ tr CQ P) < Φ 03 CO r rt rt tr 0 Φ μ μ σ P rt 0 Hi ft) ft
<! ft) Ω 0 03 TJ 3 PJ μ- ftj CD μ- X - « μ tr Φ H ftj rt rt 0 CQ s- ft d ft tr rt 0 rr μ- φ tr d ≤ Φ μ- Φ rr P <! 03 rt ft) μ- μ in μ- ft P μ Hh ?; Ω μ- Φ μ N
P d μ P ft Φ Φ ft) H- TJ Ω ft) i Ω 03 P Φ 03 0 Φ Φ ft) d 0 en 03 μ- -j ft) rt ft Ω rt ft) P d 0 ft Hh 0 Φ 0 03 P φ P CO Hi μ tr P rt t rt μ- Ω rt X tr φ μ- Ω Ω CQ 3 d ftJ rt 0 03 Ω 0 φ μ- . TJ μ- rt 03 03 P 3 tr o μ-
0 3 tr ^ 03 3 0 μ 03 TJ to ^ Φ ft 0 Ω N Ω μ tr rt -J μ- Φ Ω 0
P Φ μ- μ Φ ft) 0 rt ft) Φ μ TJ P 0 Φ H3 ftj 0 0 rt Φ Φ 3 o\° H-1 lt> P ft) rt X 0 ftj PJ CQ 03 μ ft tr ft) M Φ Ω to P ft tr 03 r P μ μ T Φ X . TJ l-h rt d 03 ft) d CQ Φ Ω d rt s P μ φ ft Φ φ Φ φ ft) CQ ft) Ω ^ d 0 0 d CQ T 1 ft) μ s; rt tr μ P 3_ 03 ft) μ- μ- 1 rt P μ s: |J μ μ Hi μ- ft) tr P μ J TJ ft) CO *> H- μ- r φ 3 0 μ- t 3» rr μ P CQ μ- 0 03 d Φ o\° TJ o
P Φ ft) rt 03 rt Ω 0 Ω Ω μ- μ ft) Φ rt 0 Hi ft μ 0 h-1 rt ft ft) μ μ Φ Ω 0 03 tr 0 Ω tr tr rt ft) Ω P to 03 . Φ P 0 φ Φ 03 in tr rt tr φ Φ ft rt Hi 1 d • 3 φ rt ft) ft o d TJ Hi ft) Φ φ tr rt ft) tr CQ p H- rt Φ μ Φ Ω o l-1 t ^-^ tSJ Ω . r
Φ t < 0 d rt 0 ≤ o
P ft H3 1— ' rt rt 0 ) o tr tr P
Φ rr ft) tr tr μ- rr B rt Hi φ μ- CO -> ft 3 0 Hi ft) o
P Φ rt ^ μ φ to tr rt o
0 tr P φ ftJ P P tr Ω o
CQ φ
Hi 3 ft μ iQ 0 Φ μ-
μ 03
13
preparation of Camembert cheese. The whey drained therein from the curd, and the cheese was turned every hour for -3 hours. The pH fell to 5.77 after 5.5 hours and to 5.11 after 18 hours, after which the cheese (cross-section 10 cm and height 3.5 cm) was salted for 1 hour in brine conventional for Gouda cheese. One day later the moisture content of the cheese was 51.0%, the fat content in the dry matter 48ι,6% and the salt content in the dry matter 3.8%. After the cheese had been dried one day at 88% relative air humidity and 13°C, the cheese was kept in a space having the same temperature but with a relative air humidity of 93%. For the first 3 days a trace suspension of the above mold was sprayed twice over the cheese. After 4 days the mold began to multiply largely and covered the whole cheese surface with a closed white layer within a few days. Unfortunately, the air velocity turned out to be too high so that the cheese dried too much the first two weeks and the ripening was delayed so that the flavor of the cheese remained too flat and the consistency too firm. This can be prevented by adjusting the air conditions.
Claims
1. A method for preparing cheese, comprising the steps of: a) concentrating milk by means of reverse osmosis or nanofiltration i.n combination with ultrafiltration and optionally diafiltration and/or microfiltration to form a concentrated milk having a content of casein which is 2-4 times higher than said content of the milk; b) adding rennet to the concentrated milk and accomplishing a first phase of a coagulating process at reduced temperature in which K casein is split and a precoagulated milk is obtained; c) carrying out a second phase of a coagulating process in which the precoagulated milk is heated to obtain a curd; d) draining the curd; and e) forming the cheese.
2. A method according to claim 1, wherein the milk is partly skimmed milk and standardized milk.
3. A method according to claim 2, wherein the milk is also thermized or pasteurized.
4. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the concentration is effected at a temperature below 20┬░C.
5. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the concentration steps consist of a nanofiltration, followed by an ultrafiltration.
6. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the concentrated milk is pasteurized before the rennet is added.
7. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein an amount of rennet is added to the concentrated milk, which amount ranges between 20 and 100 ml rennet per 100 kg of the concentrated milk. 15
8. _ A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the first phase of the coagulating process is carried out at a pH of 6.1-6.6.
9. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the first phase of the coagulating process is carried out a temperature below 20┬░C, preferably below 10┬░C.
10. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the second phase of the coagulating process is carried out at a temperature of more than 25┬░C, preferably of 30-40┬░C.
11. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the second phase of the coagulating process is carried out by mixing a stream of cold precoagulated milk with a warm liquid, said liquid being selected from water or permeate obtained by reverse osmosis or nanofiltration.
12. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, which is carried out continuously.
13. Cheese obtainable in a method according to one or more of the preceding claims.
14. Cheese according to claim 13 of the Gouda type.
15. An apparatus for use in a method for preparing cheese according to any one of claims 1-12, comprising at least one narrow metering mouth (6) for adding a stream of ultrafiltration retentate to a stream of nanofiltration permeate (4) in a tube, substantially in the direction of flow.
16. An apparatus according to claim 15, wherein the tube is provided with a constriction beyond the metering mouth, seen in the direction of flow.
17. An apparatus according to claim 15 or 16, comprising at least three metering mouths (6) .
Applications Claiming Priority (3)
| Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
|---|---|---|---|
| NL1008115 | 1998-01-23 | ||
| NL1008115A NL1008115C2 (en) | 1998-01-23 | 1998-01-23 | Method for preparing cheese. |
| PCT/NL1999/000032 WO1999037162A1 (en) | 1998-01-23 | 1999-01-18 | Method for preparing cheese |
Publications (1)
| Publication Number | Publication Date |
|---|---|
| EP1049380A1 true EP1049380A1 (en) | 2000-11-08 |
Family
ID=19766406
Family Applications (1)
| Application Number | Title | Priority Date | Filing Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| EP99900716A Withdrawn EP1049380A1 (en) | 1998-01-23 | 1999-01-18 | Method for preparing cheese |
Country Status (5)
| Country | Link |
|---|---|
| EP (1) | EP1049380A1 (en) |
| AU (1) | AU1986299A (en) |
| NL (1) | NL1008115C2 (en) |
| NZ (1) | NZ506498A (en) |
| WO (1) | WO1999037162A1 (en) |
Cited By (1)
| Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| US9775366B2 (en) | 2012-04-10 | 2017-10-03 | Kraft Foods R & D, Inc. | Process for producing cream cheese |
Families Citing this family (9)
| Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| US7169428B2 (en) | 2002-08-27 | 2007-01-30 | Select Milk Producers Inc. | Dairy compositions and method of making |
| US20070166447A1 (en) | 2002-08-27 | 2007-07-19 | Select Milk Producers, Inc. | Dairy compositions and method of making |
| WO2006066332A1 (en) * | 2004-12-23 | 2006-06-29 | Murray Goulburn Co-Operative Co Limited | Method of manufacture of a modified milk powder suitable as a rennet casein extender or replacer |
| US9055752B2 (en) | 2008-11-06 | 2015-06-16 | Intercontinental Great Brands Llc | Shelf-stable concentrated dairy liquids and methods of forming thereof |
| UA112972C2 (en) | 2010-09-08 | 2016-11-25 | Інтерконтінентал Грейт Брендс ЛЛС | LIQUID DAIRY CONCENTRATE WITH A HIGH CONTENT OF DRY SUBSTANCES |
| US10721940B2 (en) | 2011-07-21 | 2020-07-28 | Kraft Food Group Brands Llc | Methods for reducing viscosity and delaying onset of cold gelation of high solids concentrated milk products |
| CN104028129A (en) * | 2013-03-04 | 2014-09-10 | 酒泉职业技术学院 | Automatic dissolving apparatus for production of casein and automatic dissolving method |
| FR3042686B1 (en) * | 2015-10-27 | 2019-04-12 | Lactimont | PROCESS FOR PRODUCING CHEESE, FRESH PASTA TYPE CHEESE, MOLLE PASTE OR PRESSED PASTE OBTAINED IN PARTICULAR FROM SAID PROCESS |
| CN108472591A (en) * | 2015-12-21 | 2018-08-31 | 利乐拉瓦尔集团及财务有限公司 | System and method for the solid content for increasing skimmed milk or whey |
Family Cites Families (10)
| Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DK97371C (en) * | 1959-04-27 | 1963-11-18 | Nils Finn Bisgaard | Apparatus for producing foam material for insulation purposes by mixing two liquid components. |
| DK113186B (en) * | 1965-07-14 | 1969-02-24 | Alfa Laval Ab | Plants for, preferably continuous, production of cheese. |
| GB1202723A (en) * | 1967-03-20 | 1970-08-19 | Nat Res Dev | Process for the continuous production of curd |
| US3886973A (en) * | 1973-07-09 | 1975-06-03 | Phillips Petroleum Co | Production of a variegated product |
| FR2272604B1 (en) * | 1974-05-29 | 1978-06-23 | Laguilharre Pierre | |
| FR2442592A1 (en) * | 1978-06-14 | 1980-06-27 | Bel Fromageries | Cheese mfr. using retentate from milk ultrafiltration - by rennet treatment at low temp. then heating to coagulate |
| DK155704C (en) * | 1984-08-10 | 1989-09-25 | Apv Pasilac As | PLANT FOR THE PREPARATION OF ACID AND HEAT COAGULATED CHEESE |
| JPS6227030A (en) * | 1985-07-26 | 1987-02-05 | Reika Kogyo Kk | Ejector device |
| US5165945A (en) * | 1987-07-23 | 1992-11-24 | Schreiber Foods, Inc. | Cheese and process and system for making it |
| NZ228690A (en) * | 1988-04-13 | 1991-10-25 | Snow Brand Milk Products Co Ltd | Continuous production of cheese curds from ultrafiltrated milk |
-
1998
- 1998-01-23 NL NL1008115A patent/NL1008115C2/en not_active IP Right Cessation
-
1999
- 1999-01-18 NZ NZ506498A patent/NZ506498A/en unknown
- 1999-01-18 WO PCT/NL1999/000032 patent/WO1999037162A1/en not_active Ceased
- 1999-01-18 AU AU19862/99A patent/AU1986299A/en not_active Abandoned
- 1999-01-18 EP EP99900716A patent/EP1049380A1/en not_active Withdrawn
Non-Patent Citations (1)
| Title |
|---|
| See references of WO9937162A1 * |
Cited By (1)
| Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| US9775366B2 (en) | 2012-04-10 | 2017-10-03 | Kraft Foods R & D, Inc. | Process for producing cream cheese |
Also Published As
| Publication number | Publication date |
|---|---|
| WO1999037162A1 (en) | 1999-07-29 |
| NL1008115C2 (en) | 1999-07-26 |
| NZ506498A (en) | 2003-04-29 |
| AU1986299A (en) | 1999-08-09 |
Similar Documents
| Publication | Publication Date | Title |
|---|---|---|
| US4518616A (en) | Process for recovering the whey proteins, the application thereof to cheese-making and the resulting cheeses | |
| JP4474578B2 (en) | Milk protein product and process | |
| AU700748B2 (en) | Physical separation of casein and whey proteins | |
| Johnson et al. | Effect of rennet coagulation time on composition, yield, and quality of reduced-fat Cheddar cheese | |
| AU2003288836B2 (en) | Dairy protein process and applications thereof | |
| WO1999037162A1 (en) | Method for preparing cheese | |
| US5358730A (en) | Process for coagulating or gelling a nondenatured protein and product thereof | |
| JPH02308756A (en) | Cheese curd containing whey protein and preparation of cheese using the curd as raw material | |
| JPS5913171B2 (en) | Decationized milk and its production method | |
| EP0977488B1 (en) | Method for the production of cheese of the half hard type | |
| WO1983003523A1 (en) | Process for making cheese or cheese base | |
| AU772230B2 (en) | Incorporation of supersaturated lactose in process cheese | |
| EP0629349B1 (en) | Process for the preparation of a 20+ cheese or cheese product | |
| WO1986000786A1 (en) | Method for making cheese using carrageenan | |
| EP4093208A1 (en) | Preparation of brine-ripened cheese product | |
| EP1101408A1 (en) | Method for preparing a low-fat cheese | |
| WO2024008701A1 (en) | Method of removing calcium citrate from a liquid dairy stream | |
| HUT76919A (en) | The method of milk pre-treatment for cheese and quarg production |
Legal Events
| Date | Code | Title | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| PUAI | Public reference made under article 153(3) epc to a published international application that has entered the european phase |
Free format text: ORIGINAL CODE: 0009012 |
|
| 17P | Request for examination filed |
Effective date: 20000721 |
|
| AK | Designated contracting states |
Kind code of ref document: A1 Designated state(s): AT BE CH DE DK ES FI FR GB GR IE IT LI LU NL PT SE |
|
| AX | Request for extension of the european patent |
Free format text: SI PAYMENT 20000721 |
|
| 17Q | First examination report despatched |
Effective date: 20041216 |
|
| STAA | Information on the status of an ep patent application or granted ep patent |
Free format text: STATUS: THE APPLICATION IS DEEMED TO BE WITHDRAWN |
|
| 18D | Application deemed to be withdrawn |
Effective date: 20050427 |