Proxyprintery Reviews 

Honest Review of Proxyprintery
I've placed two large orders with Proxyprintery in the last two months, totalling 4,000+ cards, so I have plenty of experience with proxy retailers. Unfortunately, my experience has been increasingly disappointing.

Quality ⭐⭐⭐⭐
The print quality is genuinely good: clear text, good colour and decent card thickness. However, I've noticed slight peeling on some cards, something I haven't experienced with other high-quality proxies. It's minor once sleeved, but still a noticeable step down from MPCfill and some other sellers.

Postage & Communication ⭐⭐
This has been poor. My first order took over 10 days to receive any update, despite repeatedly contacting the company. I eventually had to track down an administrator through Discord after the website became unavailable. Tracking was also unreliable, which is particularly concerning when you've paid €500+ for an order.

Professionalism ⭐⭐
Having to download Discord and hunt down an administrator to find out where a €500+ order is doesn't inspire confidence. The website has repeatedly gone offline, and the .com and .app sites don't always appear to show the same information. At the time of writing, the website is down again, so I can't even check my order.
And honestly, forcing customers to navigate a Discord server full of people complaining about not being able to view their NSFW anime cards isn't exactly the professional first impression I'd expect from a retailer.

Price ⭐⭐
This is the real dealbreaker.
Price was originally the reason I chose Proxyprintery over MPCfill. They were significantly cheaper, making the less polished experience worthwhile. Unfortunately, they've now nearly doubled the price of their standard paper cards.
My previous 1,728-card order cost €506. Under the new pricing, the exact same order would cost approximately €972. That's an increase of over 90%.
At that price, they're roughly comparable to MPCfill, sometimes more expensive, while offering what I consider slightly lower quality and a considerably less reassuring customer experience. The previous free random-deck incentives also appear to have disappeared, further reducing the value.

Conclusion
At the old prices, I was happy to recommend Proxyprintery despite its shortcomings. The cards are good, and I've received thousands of usable proxies from them.
At the new prices, however, I simply cannot justify using them anymore. If I'm paying MPCfill money, I'd rather use MPCfill.
For anyone considering a large order, compare the current prices carefully before buying. Proxyprintery used to offer excellent value. After this price increase, I don't believe they do.
I'll be returning to MPCfill for our group's monthly orders.

The pricing policy is quite obscure. In addition to a recent increase that has changed both the cost of the single card (the price has practically doubled) also the shipping policies have only changed (before with orders over 50 euros they were free, now you need 100). In addition, social channels indicate a single card price of 0.29. On the site there is talk of 0.56, but omitting that you need a minimum order > 500 cards. I can't find a clear page that explains the costs, even opening a ticket to the assistance the answers are vague, and I've been trying for days. I'm very sorry because the service at the previous prices was very competitive, now maybe it's only convenient with huge volumes

The massive price increase is very disappointing. I have ordered once from them and while the delivery was slow the quality was quite good. I was happy to support a European company but doubling the price is just too much. A proxy deck should not cost 75.

Very expensive. Was ~0,30 cent per card if you order a lot. Which was kind of nice.

Now ~0,56 cent per card. This is not the proxy should cost.

Very long waiting time. I needed the card fix, so I ordered there as I assumed it would be fix from Germany but other are more faster and deliver from a much more distant.

I am a little bit disappointed. As my project which is why I needed the cards is now struggling.

Massive price increase, completely takes away the 'cheap option' for MTG cards.

I would be fine with 50€ for a deck but 75€ for the cheapest option is just too much.

Yes, i understand that stuff gets more expensive but here is a price increase thats more then double that, what they wanted 1-2 years ago.

Major price increase: Recent price hikes completely undermine their value proposition. MPC provides noticeably better print quality for the same price or less.

Pros:
- Excellent, intuitive order-builder app. The best I've seen so far.
- Good print quality for casual play.
- Nice packaging

Cons:
- ~2-week processing and shipping time.
- Occasional off-center cuts.

Mixed feelings about this company. At first, I was happy to find a Europe-based MTG proxy company with competitive prices. However, printing, packaging, and shipping took 11 days (Germany to Germany), which was slower than I expected. The quality is good, but not exceptional. Now they've almost doubled their prices, which makes them far less competitive compared to alternatives like makeplayingcards.com.

I also had a very poor customer service experience: I was sent a voucher code via email to get the old prices for one more week, but the code failed when I tried to apply it. Customer service apologized, explaining that the email had been delayed by their own system and that the voucher had already expired. No compensation or working code was offered — just a brief apology for the "misunderstanding." To this day, I still don't know when the code actually expired, or whether it ever worked at all.

I Ordered Cards at 04th of August. Until this day (14th of August) the Stagus is still in printing. I contactwd the support and they gave a standardized answer that its normla for a big bulk of cards to need 1-2 days extra. Im the discord they state that it needs 4-5 days until its on your door step (quote from Wiz) 10 days is too much and they didnt even send it. Also they raised the prices about almost 100%.

Great Service. Had a small issue with my Order but Support had it done in under 5 minutes. Cards also have a great quality.

The Quality is superb, the service has nothing left to wish for.

Just received my first order! Ordered a full commander deck with some additional holos and partials, and they all look amazing!

Once sleeved up, you couldn't tell the difference between them and the real deal :)

Great cost too - looking to get another 3 decks to avoid paying £££'s...

Great Customer service. The Quality of the Cards is really good. The Standard paper has a real good feel. Will order again there. Thank you.

I made an order for the normal paper quality, and it's actually pretty good, almost indistiguishable from the real mtg cards. The customer service is fast in responding and the delivery times are calculated perfectly. I'm very satisfied 😊

Customer Service was marvelous. They listened to my concerns and corrected upcoming errors perfectly.
Delivery and Production Times were as fast as one can hope.

Great service, great products at a fair price. Support is superb, can always recommend!

One of the best european proxy printer
Fast delivery, good support
The app is an good tool for custom card, you can add your original design in a gallery for use them later, it's easy to use and you can choose specifically for foil or not foil for each card

everything was perfect, customer support especially good

Great high quality proxies. I like the different style options they offer. Will definitely order more often.

Excellent MTG proxy cards starting at just €0.29 each, with free shipping on orders over €50. The old-border proxies are especially impressive, they look fantastic.

Customer support is reliable and responsive, quickly helping out or offering refunds if any issues arise. I’ve already ordered four or five times and will definitely continue ordering in the future.

Shipping is very fast as well, since everything is dispatched directly from Germany. Highly recommended!