Repository navigation
CONDITIONS
Inputs. First ruling on #3690 at 04be33cc, on arch 4f2eb87d. No since.diff, since-conditions.json, findings.json or arch-map.md is staged. So I read pr.diff whole and found the sections by search. prior-rulings.json has no ruling on this PR, on #3652, or on the bep e2e gate. No precedent applies.
Governs: Gatehouse §6.10 line 837 (helper keys in TPM 2.0 on Linux hosts) and line 844 (the node-local BEP reads host stores through one provider per store, Linux Secret Service among them). architecture.md Identity and networking line 127 (the node-local BEP on LocalVM). Personalization and data line 553 (the Linux default min secret store waits on open gap 17).
Ruling. The gate change conforms. bep_linux_key_store probes the two stores that bep uses on Linux (crates/bep/src/tpm.rs, crates/bep/src/secret_service.rs). With a store or the lane key, a proxy that does not come up fails. The Linux minvmd-build now matches the macOS recipe. Three things block the merge. (1) The store legs are NOT RUN on Linux, which matches the code (bep::store returns Unsupported off macOS) and the design (gap 17). But the reason names no issue, and the PR closes #3652, the issue that owned them (C1). (2) No lane sets E2E_BEP_KEY_STORE, and no lane is shown to have a TPM or Secret Service. So the task proof, PASS on the KVM lane, is unmet, and Fixes #3652 closes an open leg (C2, rules 4 and 6). (3) proof_bep_ahm_missing_proxy_refused keeps a Darwin exit with the reason "the Box Egress Proxy runs on macOS only". That reason is now false, and it hides a fail-closed proof (C3, rule 7). The author named all three in the PR body, but filed none.
Not checked. I did not build or run anything. I did not check that cargo build -p bep --target <musl> links, or that secret-tool lookup exits 1 with no stderr on a keyring with no match on every Secret Service backend. I did not check that the C3 refusal prints the same text on Linux as on macOS. I read the code path, and it has no cfg gate.
Conditions
- C1: File an issue in gominimal/minimal for a Linux store behind
min secretandbep::store(the Secret Service store provider, and the Linux default store of open gap 17). Inscripts/session-e2e.sh, append; Linux: <issue URL>to thenot_runreason inbep_native_store_gate(line 14196). Append it also to thebz_not_run storereason inproof_bep_dns_steering_through_the_box_zone_resolver(line 16432). List the issue as a residual in the PR body. - C2: Change
Fixes #3652in the PR body toRefs #3652. No lane setsE2E_BEP_KEY_STORE=1, and no lane is shown to have a TPM or Secret Service, so the KVM lane does not yet show the bep cases as PASS. Inscripts/session-e2e.shbep_linux_key_store, append; https://github.com/gominimal/minimal/issues/3652to bothechoreasons (lines 14186 and 14189). This gives the Linux NOT RUN lines an owner again. - C3: In
scripts/session-e2e.shproof_bep_ahm_missing_proxy_refused, remove theif [ "$(uname -s)" != "Darwin" ]block (lines 19096-19099). It records NOT RUN with "the Box Egress Proxy runs on macOS only". The refusal under test comes fromcheck_github_grantswithproxy_absenceincrates/minimal/src/cmd/boxes/create.rs. That code has no platform gate and needs no key store. Keep theMINVMD_GVPROXY_BINcheck after it. Update the comment onbep_live_gatethat says this case keeps its own Darwin check, if one does.
Ruled at 04be33c against gominimal/arch@4f2eb87d5d12 by claude-opus-5-5; arch_rulings 1561, job df5e5a54-1cf6-433d-8112-a7c563de1d41.