Top Toaster Picks
View allIt's hard to think of a breakfast less fussy than toast, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't be fussy about your toaster. If you're looking for the best toaster for your needs, there are a few main categories to consider: your basic 2-slice, a 4-slice for more capacity, and a long-slot model, which can accommodate slices from longer, taller loaves. Once you decide which is right for you, look for a model that can toast quickly and evenly while retaining enough moisture to leave the center of your bread soft rather than dry. You'll also want to consider how much counter space it takes up and whether it leaves a pile of crumbs behind after toasting. If you're willing to shell out for extra features, you might also want an option that lets you check progress mid-cycle, preferentially toast the cut side of a bagel, or consult a countdown indicator so you know exactly when it's time to start buttering.
We've tested more than 25 models, and these are our recommendations for the best toasters. For a broader look at what's available, check out our overview of the best toaster brands or, if you want to narrow down your search, see the best 2-slice toasters or the best 4-slice toasters.