Repository navigation
Error in step-up auth documentation? #37760
Unanswered
sherzinger
asked this question in
Q&A
Replies: 0 comments
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Hey,
I have question regarding the step-up authentication flow in the official documentation:
Server Administration Guide The attached picture [1] is described as:
My issue with this explanation (highlighted in bold) is the
Cookieauth step on the top, which is configured asAlternativetoAuth Flow. Would that not invalidate the entire step-up mechanism? If you have a session, it means you are authenticated and you have a cookie, consequently the logic shown here is never evaluated past the very first login attempt, and no stepping up will ever happen as long as your cookie is valid, even if the client explicitly asks for LoA 2 and you only have LoA 1.I would put
Cookieauth asAlternativeon the same level one step aboveUsername Password Form, because then it only serves as an alternative to password credentials, but does not influence the OTP sub-flow.Seeing as these are official docs, I am likely misunderstanding something, and would appreciate some help.
[1]

All reactions