8000 [PROPOSAL] Sunset inkcal.sh before it claims another finger · Issue #1 · inkitori/inkcal.sh · GitHub
[go: up one dir, main page]

Skip to content

[PROPOSAL] Sunset inkcal.sh before it claims another finger #1

Open

Description

@NotDevinLe

Summary

After spending an afternoon with this repository I am formally requesting that inkcal.sh be discontinued, archived, and possibly buried at a crossroads under a new moon.

The premise

"minimalist todo + calendar — vim-flavored, single JSON file, themeable."

Four buzzwords stapled to an Electron binary. "Minimalist" is doing competitive powerlifting in that sentence — the node_modules directory has more files than the U.S. Census. We shipped a 200MB Chromium instance so the user could press j and k. Bold.

The "vim-flavored" bit

It is j, k, dd, gg, G, and o. That is not vim flavoring. That is a vim-scented car air freshener. Real vim users are going to open this, type :wq, watch it do nothing, and never speak to us again. Fake vim users are going to press dd by accident and lose their grocery list (don't worry — there's a 5-second undo, which is exactly four seconds longer than the average human's "oh no" reflex).

The capture syntax

mwf 10:00-11:00 lecture
tr
fri: 331 hw3

Congratulations, we invented a DSL that requires a Rosetta Stone. r = thursday. u = sunday. Not th, not su — single letters, because vowels are for the weak. New users will type thu like a normal person, get a note titled "thu", and assume the app is broken. They will be correct.

The "single JSON file" architecture

Bold of us to advertise as a feature the thing every database was invented to replace. One unlucky JSON.parse away from a user's entire life dissolving into a SyntaxError. Yes, there are daily snapshots in backups/ for 30 days. No, the user does not know that. They will find out on day 31.

Themes

Three ship by default: dark, pink, light. The pink theme exists. I have no further notes on the pink theme. It speaks for itself, loudly, in pink.

The hot-reload-themes-from-a-folder feature is genuinely cute and will be used by exactly one person, who is the author. Everyone else will live in dark forever and resent us for making them scroll past pink in the palette.

The stack

electron-vite · react · tailwind · zustand · single json · ~1k loc

We used five frameworks to write 1,000 lines of code. That is one framework per 200 lines. At this density we should have just written it in bash and called it inkcal.sh — oh wait.

Functionality audit

  • Todos: exist
  • Calendar: allegedly exists
  • Notes: suspiciously exists
  • Reason to choose this over a .txt file: under investigation
  • Reason to choose this over Apple Reminders, which ships free, syncs, and was written by people with QA budgets: none found

Recommendation

  1. Archive the repo.
  2. Delete ~/Library/Application Support/inkcal-sh/ from every machine that has ever run it, as a courtesy.
  3. Open Notes.app. Type your todo. You're done. You saved 200MB.
  4. Reflect.

Severity

Existential.

Activity

  1. inkitori commented on May 4, 2026

    @inkitori
    Owner

    yo

  2. inkitori commented on May 4, 2026

    @inkitori
    Owner

    gurt

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions

      0