8000 kagent → AX → Substrate: Making AX the Runtime Boundary for Agent Applications · Issue #454 · google/ax · GitHub
[go: up one dir, main page]

Skip to content

kagent → AX → Substrate: Making AX the Runtime Boundary for Agent Applications #454

Closed

Description

@ssrq1992

kagent → AX → Substrate: Making AX the Runtime Boundary for Agent Applications

I've implemented and deployed an integration that changes kagent's runtime dependency from kagent → Substrate to kagent → AX → Substrate.

The stack runs on Kubernetes with gVisor. In the demo, I create an Agent through the kagent UI, let AX prepare its runtime, and start a conversation with a DeepSeek-backed agent.

The main idea is to make AX the runtime interface that kagent depends on: kagent owns the application and its sessions; AX owns the runtime contract; Substrate provides the underlying execution mechanisms.

Implementation repositories:

The additions described below are part of this integration, not features I am claiming are already available in upstream AX. The repository links point to development branches and may change after this post.

1. Why introduce AX between kagent and Substrate?

In the kagent version I started from, kagent directly used Substrate to create and run agent instances. Substrate already provided the essential mechanisms: Actors, WorkerPools, isolation, snapshots, and suspend/resume.

However, kagent also had to translate application requirements into those infrastructure resources. Creating a conversational agent involved constructing an ActorTemplate, preparing a golden snapshot, selecting a WorkerPool, creating an Actor, and handling backend routing. Checkpoint/fork and sandbox operations introduced further dependencies on snapshot semantics and the Guest protocol.

This left two kinds of logic in kagent:

  • Application logic: models, prompts, tools, sessions, conversation history, permissions, and scheduled runs.
  • Runtime integration: templates, capacity, instance lifecycle, backend addressing, snapshots, and execution protocols.

AX's existing Task abstraction offered a starting point for separating them. Rather than asking every agent application to implement its own Substrate integration, AX can expose a runtime contract that applications share.

That is the value I wanted to explore: an application should be able to ask AX to prepare, create, access, and restore an agent instance without constructing Substrate resources itself.

Adding AX also adds a service boundary and operational complexity. The abstraction needs to cover the whole interaction surface to justify that cost. Moving Actor creation behind AX while leaving WorkerPool management and backend routing in kagent would only partially solve the problem.

2. Goals and responsibilities

The integration has four goals:

  1. Make AX models and APIs the runtime dependency exposed to kagent.
  2. Cover runtime preparation, capacity, lifecycle, and access together.
  3. Preserve kagent's sessions, A2A behavior, history, credentials, scheduled runs, checkpoint/fork, and sandbox capabilities.
  4. Extend AX while retaining its ordinary Task execution path.

The intended division of responsibilities is:

Layer What it owns
kagent What the Agent does, who can use it, and how its sessions and application history work
AX How the runtime is prepared, which capacity it uses, how an instance is identified and accessed, and how its lifecycle is managed
Substrate How Actors execute, how worker capacity is provided, and how isolation, snapshots, and backend networking work

This does not make backend changes free. It gives those changes a defined integration boundary in AX instead of spreading them through kagent's business services.

3. Architecture

flowchart TB
    subgraph K["kagent — application layer"]
        Config["Harness + AgentTemplate<br/>Compile a runtime revision"]
        Session["Session / Sandbox<br/>Lifecycle and checkpoint / fork"]
        Dialer["RuntimeDialer<br/>A2A access"]
    end

    subgraph A["AX — runtime interface"]
        Prepared["PreparedRuntime<br/>Prepare and reuse"]
        Group["TaskGroup<br/>Shared capacity"]
        Task["Task<br/>Runtime instance"]
        Gateway["Shared TaskGateway<br/>Route by Task UID"]
        Prepared -->|"Referenced by"| Task
        Group -->|"Hosts"| Task
        Gateway -->|"Targets"| Task
    end

    subgraph S["Substrate — execution backend"]
        Template["ActorTemplate + golden snapshot"]
        Pool["WorkerPool"]
        Actor["Actor"]
    end

    Config -->|"Compile and prepare"| Prepared
    Config -->|"Select group"| Group
    Session -->|"AX lifecycle APIs"| Task
    Dialer -->|"A2A over mTLS"| Gateway
    Prepared --> Template
    Group -->|"1:1"| Pool
    Task -->|"1:1"| Actor
Loading

The diagram shows logical relationships, not every network hop. Backend resource mappings stay inside AX. kagent does not construct ActorTemplates, manage WorkerPools, or address Actors directly.

4. The key design choices

TaskGroup: replace direct WorkerPool management

TaskGroup represents shared runtime capacity. In this implementation, one TaskGroup maps to one Substrate WorkerPool.

Its configuration is deliberately small:

Field Meaning
replicas Number of workers, not the number of Tasks or Agents
sandboxClass The platform's supported isolation class, such as gvisor
snapshotLocation Snapshot storage location

Multiple Harnesses and sessions can share a TaskGroup. Each Task binds to its group using a name and UID, preventing an existing reference from silently attaching to a different group recreated under the same name.

I initially considered a batch-oriented resource, but the semantics did not fit. Sessions arrive over time. The group should provide capacity, not maintain a fixed number of Tasks or replace a deleted session.

The implementation includes scaling checks and reference protection for deletion. TaskGroups can be created while AX Server is running; they do not have to be declared at startup. The CLI currently provides ax group create|get|list|scale|delete. TaskGroup is an AX API resource, not a Kubernetes CRD, and ax apply does not yet handle it.

PreparedRuntime: prepare an environment before creating sessions

PreparedRuntime separates preparing an Agent's environment from creating a particular session instance.

kagent compiles a Harness and AgentTemplate into an immutable revision. It then calls AX to prepare the image, command, runtime configuration, readiness requirements, and credential bindings. AX translates that configuration into the backend template and golden snapshot—the prepared starting state used to instantiate runtimes.

The lifecycle is Prepare / Get / Release. kagent publishes Agent readiness only after preparation succeeds and the usable revision is persisted. Old revisions are released through reference-aware cleanup.

Many sessions can reuse a prepared starting environment, while each session retains its own runtime state and identity. Creating an Agent therefore does not immediately create a user session's Task. A golden Actor used during preparation is separate from a session instance.

Managed Tasks: replace direct Actor lifecycle operations

For the conversation path, one kagent Session binds to one AX Task, backed by one Actor. An A2A Task still represents application work within that session; it is not the same thing as the AX runtime instance.

The managed path adds groupRef, preparedRuntimeRef, optional restoreFrom, and separate runtime status. It covers create, resume, pause, suspend, delete, and checkpoint operations.

Ordinary Tasks retain their existing path. Persisted ownership distinguishes managed resources, so omitting managed fields from a later request cannot bypass the managed-resource checks.

Shared TaskGateway: hide backend addressing

kagent's RuntimeDialer sends A2A traffic to a shared TaskGateway inside AX Server. The gateway validates access, identifies the target Task by UID, resumes it when needed, and forwards requests through Substrate's routing path.

This is an added service capability within AX Server, not a separate gateway deployment for each group. A stateful conversation must reach its own Task rather than an arbitrary instance in the group.

The gateway supports A2A unary calls, streaming, and cancellation. Sandbox process and filesystem operations use AX's TaskExecutionService, with AX-owned messages and backend Guest protocol conversion inside AX.

Together, these changes move the dependency boundary beyond simply replacing an Actor reference with a Task reference.

5. What happens during a conversation?

Prepare the Agent

An operator creates or selects a TaskGroup. In kagent, a Harness chooses the adapter, runtime image, and group; an AgentTemplate defines the model, prompt, and tools; an Agent combines the two.

sequenceDiagram
    actor U as User / operator
    participant K as kagent
    participant A as AX
    participant S as Substrate

    U->>A: Create or select TaskGroup
    A->>S: Ensure corresponding worker capacity
    U->>K: Configure model, Harness, template, and Agent
    K->>A: Resolve TaskGroup UID
    K->>K: Compile immutable runtime revision
    K->>A: PrepareRuntime with stable request identity
    A->>S: Prepare template and golden snapshot
    loop Observe preparation
        K->>A: GetPreparedRuntime
        A-->>K: Preparation status
    end
    Note over K,A: Successful preparation
    K->>K: Persist usable revision and AX references
    K-->>U: Agent Ready
Loading

No manual PreparedRuntime creation is needed: the kagent controller drives this process.

Create the session and handle the first message

The current UI creates the Session when the user submits the first message. Internally, session creat 8000 ion and message dispatch are separate steps: kagent records the creation intent, creates the AX Task, and persists its binding before dispatching the message.

sequenceDiagram
    actor U as User
    participant K as kagent / TaskStore
    participant A as AX / TaskGateway
    participant S as Substrate
    participant R as ADK runtime
    participant M as Model API

    U->>K: Start a conversation with a message
    K->>K: Record Session and stable creation intent
    K->>A: CreateTask with group and runtime references
    A->>S: Create suspended Actor and runtime bindings
    A-->>K: Task identity
    K->>K: Persist Session-to-Task binding
    K->>A: Dispatch A2A request to Task UID
    A->>A: Validate caller and target
    opt Task needs activation
        A->>S: Resume instance
        S->>R: Restore runtime and check readiness
    end
    A->>R: Route A2A request through backend
    R->>K: HTTPS TaskStore call with runtime credential
    K->>A: Authenticate runtime
    A-->>K: Verified Task identity
    K->>K: Validate Session binding
    K-->>R: Session identity and requested business state
    R->>R: Use instance-local ADK conversation state
    R->>M: Call model through configured egress
    M-->>R: Model output
    R-->>A: A2A events
    A-->>K: Forward events
    K-->>U: Display response
    R->>K: Persist business state and coordinate completion
    K->>A: Request lifecycle transition when appropriate
    A->>S: Perform backend transition
    K->>A: Observe completion
    A-->>K: Runtime state and boundary reference
    K->>K: Persist boundary
Loading

This is a logical sequence. Streaming and state writes may interleave, and subsequent TaskStore requests still require authentication. kagent's public business history is distinct from the ADK runtime's private conversation state, stored in the instance's durable directory.

A later message in the same Session targets the same Task UID. If the Task is suspended, AX restores it; otherwise, it routes to the running instance. A boundaryRef identifies the recorded runtime boundary without making kagent handle backend snapshot addresses.

Checkpoint/fork builds on that separation: kagent owns the business history cutoff and creates a new Session, while AX creates a new Task from a validated restore reference. Deleting a Session cleans up its Task without deleting shared capacity or prepared runtimes that remain referenced.

6. The working demo

Environment

The demo runs on an existing Kubernetes cluster with:

  • Substrate using gVisor (sandboxClass: gvisor).
  • The extended AX Server and persistent Redis.
  • The paired kagent controller, UI, CRDs, and ADK runtime image, with PostgreSQL.
  • mTLS access to AX, HTTPS runtime callbacks, and the outbound credential and trust configuration needed for model calls.

The application path requires more than healthy Pods: model access, runtime credential injection, and TaskStore callbacks must also work.

current-context

Create a TaskGroup

The group used in the demo was:

apiVersion: ax.dev/v1alpha1
kind: TaskGroup
metadata:
  name: kagent-task-group-demo
  atespace: kagent
spec:
  replicas: 1
  sandboxClass: gvisor
  snapshotLocation: gs://ate-snapshots/kagent-ssd

With the AX endpoint and client certificates configured:

ax --server "$AX_ENDPOINT" --atespace kagent group create \
  --file "$DEMO_DIR/task-group-demo.yaml" \
  --request-id create-kagent-demo

ax --server "$AX_ENDPOINT" --atespace kagent group get \
  --name kagent-task-group-demo

The snapshot location is specific to this deployment. Retrying the same creation uses the same request identity; a different operation should not reuse it.

The creation returned Provisioning, followed by Ready with one ready worker:

create-TaskGroup get-TaskGroup

The corresponding WorkerPool and worker Pod were ready. This is an operator-side inspection of the mapping, not a direct dependency in kagent's application path:

get-workerpools

Configure the Agent through the UI

The actual demo used these resources:

Resource Demo configuration
ModelConfig deepseek-v4-pro, using the OpenAI-compatible provider and model ID deepseek-v4-pro
Model endpoint https://api.deepseek.com
Harness kagent-harness-demo, with the kagent adapter and a digest-pinned ADK image
TaskGroup kagent-task-group-demo
AgentTemplate kagent-template-demo, with a general-knowledge assistant prompt
Agent deepseek-agent-demo, referencing that template and Harness

The model API key is stored in a Kubernetes Secret. The runtime receives a credential binding rather than embedding the actual key in the shared runtime configuration.

The Harness form selects AX capacity directly. This particular demo also set a snapshot-location override; leaving it unset would use the group's location.

new-harness

The template supplies the model and prompt:

new-template

The Agent references both resources:

new-agent

After AX preparation completed, the Agent appeared as Ready:

get-agent

Start a conversation and inspect its runtime

I opened the Agent and sent two messages: “who are you?” and “what can you do?” The UI displayed responses from the configured agent:

chat

Inspecting the Session's AX Task showed its UID-bound TaskGroup and PreparedRuntime references, together with a recorded suspend boundary:

task-info

The Task output contains executionVersion: 3, an idle Suspend operation, a boundaryRef, and restorable: true. This is a post-execution observation; it should not be mistaken for a capture immediately after initial Task creation.

The corresponding PreparedRuntime query reported kind: Service and phase: Ready. The following selected fields show the runtime-to-group relationship:

{
  "metadata": {
    "name": "deepseek-agent-demo-5fb960b71a51",
    "atespace": "kagent",
    "uid": "24bfc8f1265b8ce5068360f39ae20828"
  },
  "spec": {
    "groupRef": {
      "atespace": "kagent",
      "name": "kagent-task-group-demo",
      "uid": "5cde9957076ba25dfb2cb18bcc0477ed"
    },
    "kind": "Service"
  },
  "phase": "Ready"
}

Originally posted by @ssrq1992 in #447

Activity

  1. changed the title [-]# kagent → AX → Substrate: Making AX the Runtime Boundary for Agent Applications[/-] [+]kagent → AX → Substrate: Making AX the Runtime Boundary for Agent Applications[/+] on Oct 8, 2026
  2. rakyll commented on Oct 27, 2026

    @rakyll
    Member

    Thank you for the proposal. Because AX and kagent operate on separate stacks, integrating this workflow falls outside the current scope of AX. We are going to close this issue, but we appreciate you sharing your integration work with the community.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions

      0