There are 3 ways to get from Sparta to Shelter Island by bus, unknown, or train
Select an option below to see step-by-step directions and to compare ticket prices and travel times in Rome2Rio's travel planner.
Bus, travel
best- Take the bus from Rt 23 Southbound At St Johns Church to Port Authority Bus Terminalbus 194
- Take the bus from 79th St & Broadway to Sag Harbor Westboundbus
- Walk from Sag Harbor Westbound to Shelter Islandunknown
5h 12mTrain, travel
- Take the train from Dover to New York Penn Stationtrain Mne
- Take the train from New York Penn Station to Ronkonkomatrain
- Take the train from Ronkonkoma to Greenporttrain
- Walk from Greenport to Shelter Islandunknown
5h 53mBus, travel via Rt-23 Park & Ride At Kanouse Rd
- Take the bus from Rt-23 Park & Ride At Kanouse Rd to Port Authority Bus Terminalbus 194
- Take the bus from Boerum Hill-Atlantic & 4 Av to Greenportbus
- Walk from Greenport to Shelter Islandunknown
6h 36m
Comparing Your Travel Options
The distance between Sparta and Shelter Island is 199 miles.
The best way to get from Sparta to Shelter Island without a car is to bus and travel which takes 5h 12m and costs .
It takes approximately 5h 12m to get from Sparta to Shelter Island, including transfers.
There are 176+ hotels available in Shelter Island.
What companies run services between Sparta, NJ, USA and Shelter Island, NY, USA?
There is no direct connection from Sparta to Shelter Island. However, you can take the taxi to Rt 23 Southbound At St Johns Church, take the bus to Port Authority Bus Terminal, walk to W 41 St/8 Av, take the bus to Broadway/W 77 St, walk to 79th St & Broadway, take the bus to Sag Harbor Westbound, then travel to Shelter Island. Alternatively, you can take a vehicle from Sparta to Shelter Island via Dover, New York Penn Station, Ronkonkoma, and Greenport in around 5h 53m.
- Phone
- +1 973-275-5555
- Website
- New Jersey Transit
Train from Dover to New York Penn Station
- Ave. Duration
- 1h 28m
- Frequency
- Hourly
- Estimated price
- $3–21
- Website
- New Jersey Transit
- Website
- NJ Transit: World Cup 2026
- Adult
- $3–21
- Phone
- +1-718-217-5477
- Website
- Long Island Rail Road
Train from New York Penn Station to Ronkonkoma
- Ave. Duration
- 1h 22m
- Frequency
- Every 30 minutes
- Estimated price
- $13–30
- Website
- Long Island Rail Road
- Schedules at
- Long Island Rail Road Schedules
- Off-Peak
- $13–19
- Peak
- $22–30
Train from Ronkonkoma to Greenport
- Ave. Duration
- 1h 24m
- Frequency
- 3 times a day
- Estimated price
- $9–24
- Website
- Long Island Rail Road
- Schedules at
- Long Island Rail Road Schedules
- Off-Peak
- $9–13
- Peak
- $19–24
- Phone
- +1 973-275-5555
- Website
- New Jersey Transit
Bus from Rt 23 Southbound At St Johns Church to Port Authority Bus Terminal
- Ave. Duration
- 1h 10m
- Frequency
- Every 4 hours
- Estimated price
- $10–35
- Website
- New Jersey Transit
- Website
- NJ Transit: World Cup 2026
- Adults
- $10–35
Bus from Rt-23 Park & Ride At Kanouse Rd to Port Authority Bus Terminal
- Ave. Duration
- 1h 29m
- Frequency
- Hourly
- Estimated price
- $10–35
- Website
- New Jersey Transit
- Website
- NJ Transit: World Cup 2026
- Adults
- $10–35
- Phone
- +1 631.283.4600
- Website
- Hampton Jitney
Bus from 79th St & Broadway to Sag Harbor Westbound
- Ave. Duration
- 2h 40m
- Frequency
- On demand
- Estimated price
- $30–75
- Website
- Hampton Jitney
- Schedules at
- Hampton Jitney Schedule Information
- Book at
- Hampton Jitney Reservations
- Onboard
- $40–50
- Ambassador
- $60–75
- Prepaid Online Rate
- $30–40
Bus from Boerum Hill-Atlantic & 4 Av to Greenport
- Ave. Duration
- 3h 58m
- Frequency
- On demand
- Estimated price
- $30–75
- Website
- Hampton Jitney
- Schedules at
- Hampton Jitney Schedule Information
- Book at
- Hampton Jitney Reservations
- Onboard
- $40–50
- Ambassador
- $60–75
- Prepaid Online Rate
- $30–40
Want to know more about travelling around United States
Rome2Rio's Travel Guide series provide vital information for the global traveller. Filled with useful and timely travel information, the guides answer all the hard questions - such as 'How do I buy a ticket?', 'Should I book online before I travel? ', 'How much should I expect to pay?', 'Do the trains and buses have Wifi?' - to help you get the most out of your next trip.